Browse Topic: Impact tests

Items (738)
Accurate simulation of fluid-structure interactions (FSI) is critical for designing aircraft systems, particularly for applications involving fuel tank sloshing and large deformations. Traditional added mass methods often fail to capture the nonlinear and frequency-dependent behavior of these coupled systems. This study applies the Finite Pointset Method (FPM), a mesh-free computational fluid dynamics (CFD) technique, coupled with an explicit finite element solver, to predict complex FSI phenomena. Validation is performed using benchmark experiments, including a harmonic tank sloshing test and a guided plate ditching scenario, with results demonstrating strong agreement with measured pressures and structural responses. Additional validation on a composite fuel tank drop impact test confirms FPM's ability to model large deformations and rupture under dynamic loading. The findings highlight FPM's robustness and adaptability for aerospace FSI problems, offering a powerful alternative for virtual prototyping and certification workflows where conventional methods are insufficient.
Dwarampudi, RameshVaz, Ignatius
To validate simulation work towards the design of the Dragonfly rotorcraft lander, a process of extracting a modal model from impact test data is described in this paper. Through a curve-fitting process using Siemens Testlab software, modal frequencies, damping, and mode shapes are extracted and mass-normalized to be imported as a modal model into the Rotorcraft Comprehensive Analysis System (RCAS) to represent the dynamics of the underlying structure more accurately. Wind tunnel conditions were simulated to compare to hub loads measured during wind tunnel testing. An initial comparison of RCAS with VVPM inflow and RCAS coupled with HELIOS show similar hub loads but also show the importance of modeling the rotational degrees of freedom of the structure properly. Additional modeling comparisons between modeling the hubs and the load cell locations further illustrate that by capturing rotational mode shapes based on test data, in-plane hub loads are predicted more accurately.
Vermillion, Therese-AnnModarres, RaminWelsh, BillZhao, JinggenKim, JeewoongPeterson, DanielRuiz, FelipeLynch, TimothyYoung, Daniel
As part of a larger project aimed at gaining a better understanding of factors that affect the quality of test results using anthropomorphic test devices (ATDs), the FAA tested the effects of dynamic loading of an ATD pelvis. The ATDs required in the aviation regulations were initially developed for the automotive crash environment, which does not include a vertical testing component. One of the two dynamic tests is a vertical impact, with the principal measurement being the compressive load in the lumbar spinal column, with a regulatory limit of 1500 lb. The lumbar load cell is mounted to the pelvis, and data collected could be affected by the performance of the ATD pelvis. The ability to define a vertical calibration test could be used to determine if the pelvis is acceptable for initial use or to monitor in-service degradation. Three ATD pelvises were compressed in a high-rate load frame. The peak load and loading rate of the pelvis compression were selected to simulate conditions achieved in transport category aircraft vertical seat testing. The primary test objective was to measure changes to the rubber and foam cover of the metallic pelvis during high cyclic loading. Each pelvis was subjected to over 100 cycles. Static dimensional measurements, based on a manufacturing tolerance evaluation, were collected during testing. The high-cycle testing did not deform the foam and rubber covers enough to exceed the total dimensional tolerance of the pelvises (± 0.120 in.). The appearance of visual damage was closely monitored throughout the testing. Similar visual damage was seen for each pelvis and occurred at low cycles — 15 to 30. Results suggest the appearance of damage minimally changed the dynamic response of the pelvis. Force-deflection data were also collected from each test series. These data showed minimal change during testing, with the deflection at 2000 lb. changing approximately 0.100 in. across the 105 cycles. This value is similar to the manufacturer’s tolerance for the height of the pelvis. Based on this, the number of vertical sled tests that would precipitate replacement may be over 100 cycles. Due to the harsh environment of dynamic sled testing, other factors, such as cuts in the foam and rubber due to belt loading, may trigger the removal of an ATD pelvis from service prior to the pelvis reaching a defined number of cycles. Future FAA research will evaluate how this change in pelvis force-deflection affects lumbar load.
Hellstrom, IanMoorcroft, DavidCarroll, William
The AW609 tiltrotor features a unique high-mounted wing with rotatable nacelles positioned at the wing tips, it is capable of operating both in airplane and vertical flight mode. To achieve suited protection of the occupants during emergency landing, the wing - which is particularly stiff in order to sustain the heavy weights at the tips, where rotors, engines and transmissions are positioned - implements a controlled failure mechanism at root, so that during emergency landings it breaks and unloads the fuselage of the weight of wingbox and nacelles, thus avoiding catastrophic collapse. As the effectiveness of such mechanism was never demonstrated under impact conditions, certification agencies requested an empirical validation through experimental testing. The test was carried out July 2022 at Polytechnic of Milan, Italy; the present work details the Test activity, from its preliminary phases to the Test Day, to the analyses of its outcomes.
Colamartino, IvanCavalera, DavideTurconi, FabrizioAnghileri, MarcoDi Renzo, Andrea
This paper presents the results of a research and development (R&D) effort focused on fluid structure interactions between airframe structures and bladder type fuel tanks during a crash environment. During this R&D effort, fuel tank and surrounding structure crash impact tests were conducted using an innovative test configuration that allowed low-cost fabrication of test articles which represented several different design architectures. LS-DYNA models of the crash test article configurations were also developed and correlated with the tests data. Good correlation between the test data and LS-DYNA analysis results was achieved. The paper also includes recommendations for design of the airframe structures around the fuel tanks based on the fluid structure interaction insights gained from the crash tests and analyses.
Bolukbasi, AkifWeisenburger, Richard
ABSTRACT
Putnam, JacobLittell, Justin
ABSTRACT
Littell, JustinPutnam, Jacob
This SAE Recommended Practice describes a laboratory test procedure and requirements for evaluating the characteristics of heavy-truck steering control systems under simulated driver impact conditions, as well as driver entry/egress conditions. The test procedure employs a torso-shaped body block that is impacted against the steering wheel.
Truck Crashworthiness Committee
This specification covers an aircraft-quality, low-alloy steel in the form of bars, forgings, mechanical tubing, and forging stock.
AMS E Carbon and Low Alloy Steels Committee
ABSTRACT
Cooper, MeganLittell, JustinPutnam,  Jacob
This SAE Recommended Practice describes the test procedures for conducting simulated dynamic lateral rollover restraint system tests for heavy truck applications. Its purpose is to establish recommended test procedures that will standardize restraint system testing for heavy trucks. Descriptions of the test set-up, test instrumentation, photographic/video coverage, and the test fixtures are included.
Truck Crashworthiness Committee
This SAE Recommended Practice describes the test procedures for conducting frontal impact restraint tests for heavy truck applications. Its purpose is to establish recommended test procedures that will standardize restraint system testing for heavy trucks. Descriptions of the test set-up, test instrumentation, photographic/video coverage, and the test fixtures are included.
Truck Crashworthiness Committee
Evaluation of General Motors Event Data Recorder Performance in Semi-Trailer Rear Underride Collisions2020-01-13284/14/2020
The objective of this study was to analyze the validity of airbag control module data in semi-trailer rear underride collisions. These impacts involve unusual collision dynamics, including long crash pulses and minimal bumper engagement [1]. For this study, publicly available data from 16 semi-trailer underride guard crash tests performed by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) were used to form conclusions about the accuracy of General Motors airbag control module (ACM) delta-V (ΔV) data in a semi-trailer rear underride scenario. These tests all utilized a 2009 or 2010 Chevrolet Malibu impacting a stationary 48’ or 53’ semi-trailer at a speed of 35 mph. Nine tests were fully overlapped collisions, six were 30% overlapped, and one was 50% overlapped [2]. The IIHS test vehicles were equipped with calibrated 10000 Hz accelerometer units. Event Data Recorder (EDR) data imaged post-accident from the test vehicles were compared to the reference IIHS data. For each test, root mean square error (RMSE), the percent error over time, and the difference between the EDR ΔV and the IIHS ΔV, was quantified, plotted, and related to crash pulse. This analysis revealed a general trend of decreasing EDR ΔV parity with an increasing crash pulse duration, although overall differences remained low for most tests. Eleven tests, all with airbag deployments, converged towards an average of 3.3% error at the end of the crash pulse, which were 150-270 ms. EDR recorded ΔVs were in the range of 29.8-39.9 mph. Five tests, three of which were non-deployments, diverged to higher percentage error averaging 12.7% at an EDR ΔV of 31.8-40.0 mph. All higher error tests were 30% overlapped and had the highest crash pulse durations of 240-300 ms. One fully overlapped test generated highly unusual EDR data due to failure of the rear underride guard mounting bolts and plates.
Famiglietti, NicholasHoang, RyanFatzinger, EdwardLanderville, Jon
Fuel Tank Dynamic Strain Measurement Using Computer Vision Analysis2020-01-09244/14/2020
Stress and strain measurement of high density polyethylene (HDPE) fuel tanks under dynamic loading is challenging. Motion tracking combined with computer vision was employed to evaluate the strain in an HDPE fuel tank being dynamically loaded with a crash pulse. Traditional testing methods such as strain gages are limited to the small strain elastic region and HDPE testing may exceed the range of the strain gage. In addition, strain gages are limited to a localized area and are not able to measure the deformation and strain across a discontinuity such as a pinch seam. Other methods such as shape tape may not have the response time needed for a dynamic event. Motion tracking data analysis was performed by tracking the motion of specified points on a fuel tank during a dynamic test. An HDPE fuel tank was mounted to a vehicle section and a sled test was performed using a Seattle sled to simulate a high deltaV crash. Multiple target markers were placed on the fuel tank. The motion of these markers was captured using high speed video cameras. The high speed videos were processed using the OpenCV computer vision library. Using OpenCV, the high speed videos were imported, and the position of the central location of each target marker was extracted frame by frame from the high speed videos. Once the position was known, the strain was computed using the change in relative position between two marker positions. Results of the testing showed that the acceleration-induced strain is low, generally less than the material yield strain. It was noted that reliable and accurate results require that the camera be placed normal to, or at a shallow angle to, the points being tracked. In addition, curved surfaces lead to limited fidelity of strain data due to the varying focal length of the points being tracked and measurement increased sensitivity. This method is similar to a “typical” tensile test in which displacement is tracked between two pre-established points on a sample. As such, the methodology was replicated on a tensile specimen to validate the methodology.
Fleming, MarkKrishnaswami, RamNakamoto, Kunihiro
SUV Kinematics during a Steer-Induced Rollover Resolved Using Consumer-Grade Video, Laser Scans and Match-Moving Techniques2020-01-06424/14/2020
Rollover crashes are complex events that generate motions in all six degrees of freedom (6DOF). Directly quantifying the angular rotations from video can be difficult and vehicle orientation as a function of time is often not reported for staged rollover crashes. Our goal was to evaluate the ability of using a match-moving technique and consumer-grade video cameras to quantify the roll, pitch and yaw angles and angular velocities of a rollover crash. We staged a steer-induced rollover of an SUV at 106 km/h. The vehicle was fitted with tri-axial accelerometers and angular rate sensors, and five consumer-grade video cameras (2 on tripods, 2 on drones, 1 handheld, ~30 fps) captured the event. Roll, pitch and yaw angles were determined from the video using specialized software. We then compared the vehicle orientation angles from the video data to the integrated angular rate data measured by onboard sensors, and also compared the angular rates from the differentiated video data to the angular rates measured directly by the sensors. We found that both methods of measuring the 3D angles and angular rates generated similar results. The integrated sensor data drifted a maximum of 13° relative to the video-based angles, with RMS differences of ±2.7° or less when the drift was removed. The differentiated video data did not drift relative to the sensor data, with RMS differences of ±0.22 rad/s or less. These findings indicate that both methods generate similar results and are suitable for reconstructing rollovers. Given the drift we observed in the integrated sensor data, we recommend using angle measurements from the video to quantify the amount of drift in integrated sensor data if accurate knowledge of the vehicle’s orientation as a function of time is important.
Young, Cole R.King, David J.Siegmund, Gunter P.
Using Vehicle EDR Data to Calculate Motorcycle Delta-V in Motorcycle-Vehicle Lateral Front End Impacts2020-01-08854/14/2020
This research focuses on the use of Event Data Recorders (EDR) to assist in calculating speed loss or ΔV undergone by a motorcycle in a broadside type impact into a vehicle. If the struck vehicle has EDR data, this could be a useful tool in calculating motorcycle ΔV or corroborating motorcycle ΔV calculations from crush or other methodologies. Certain parameters critical to calculation of motorcycle ΔV must be considered, including the appropriate effective mass to use for the motorcycle/rider combination. This study used crash test data to determine a method of applying parameter values to accurately calculate motorcycle ΔV in a motorcycle-vehicle collision. In this study, three crash tests were performed in which a motorcycle with a dummy rider traveling in the range of 42 to 51 mph collided into the right front corner of a vehicle traveling between 5 and 16 mph. In all three tests, both the vehicle and motorcycle were instrumented with triaxial accelerometers and triaxial rate gyros. The first test involved a 2002 Kawasaki ZRX1200R traveling at 42.2 mph into the right front corner of a 2009 Chevrolet Malibu traveling at 5 mph. The impact occurred just forward of the vehicle’s right front wheel area. The second test involved a 2006 Yamaha YZF-R6 traveling at 48.1 mph into the right front corner of a 2012 Ford Focus traveling at 14 mph. The impact occurred near the vehicle’s right front headlight/bumper reinforcement area. The third test involved a 2013 Kawasaki Ninja EX300 traveling at 50.5 mph into the right front corner of a 2015 Nissan Sentra traveling at 9 mph. Again, the impact occurred near the vehicle’s right front headlight/bumper reinforcement area. In all the tests, the vehicle ACM-recorded data underreported the longitudinal ΔV in the range of 0.8-1.3 mph. Additionally, in all tests the vehicle ACM-recorded data overreported the lateral ΔV by 0.4-0.5 mph. This overreporting was present after adjustments were made for the ACM location. Overall, the EDR data was able to predict the motorcycle ΔV within a range of -5.9 mph to +3.1 mph. The underpredicted values were calculated with full rider and motorcycle weight, and the overpredicted values were calculated with half the rider weight.
Fatzinger, EdwardLanderville, Jon
Far Side Impact Injury Threshold Recommendations Based on 6 Paired WorldSID / Post Mortem Human Subjects Tests2019-22-00053/31/2020
Far side has been identified in the literature as a potential cause of numerous injuries and fatalities. Euro NCAP developed a far side test protocol to be performed to assess adult protection. A monitoring phase was undertaken between January 2018 and December 2019, and the far side assessment will become part of the rating for all vehicles launched in 2020 onward. A test buck was developed and 6 paired WorldSID / Post Mortem Human Subjects (PMHS) were subjected to the test protocol proposed by Euro NCAP to contribute to the development of limits. The buck consisted of a rigid seat and a rigid central console covered with 50 mm of Ethafoam TM 180 with a density of 16 kg/m3. The buck was mounted on the sled with an angle of 75° between the X axis of the vehicle and the X axis of the sled. The peak head excursion was compared between PMHS and the WorldSID dummy. It was found reasonably similar. However, the dummy repeatability was found to be poor. Out of 6 tests conducted on 6 PMHS, 2 specimens sustained AIS3 and, 3 specimens AIS2 cervical spine injuries, 3 specimens sustained AIS3, 1 AIS2 and 1 AIS1 thoracic injuries, and 2 specimens sustained AIS2 abdominal injuries. The peak values recorded on the dummy according to the Euro NCAP protocol were compared with the injury assessments of the PMHS tests. In the configuration used, which includes a central console, the hard thorax injury prediction was found to be excellent. For the neck injury prediction, the data were merged with similar results available in the literature and an Injury Risk Curve was proposed as a derivative from the curve published by Mertz et al. (2003) for neck extension.
Petit, PhilippeTrosseille, XavierUriot, JéromePoulard, DavidPotier, PascalBaudrit, PascalCompigne, SabineKunisada, MasatoTsurui, Kenji
Finite Element Modeling of an Energy-Absorbing Guardrail End Terminal02-12-04-00212/7/2020
Guardrail end terminals are specifically designed to decelerate vehicles during impact and protect vehicle occupants from severe injuries. The main objective of this research was to develop and validate a Finite Element (FE) model of the ET-Plus, a commonly used energy-absorbing guardrail end terminal. The ET-Plus FE model was created based on publicly available data on ET-Plus dimensions and material properties. The model was validated against the NCHRP-350 crash tests 27-30 and 31-30 by performing crash simulations with a vehicle model at 100 km/h (62 mph) pre-impact velocity. To check the model robustness, crash simulations with vehicle pre-impact velocities from 97 km/h (60 mph) to 113 km/h (70 mph) were also performed. The developed ET-Plus FE model has a high-quality mesh and can replicate the energy-absorbing mechanism. The time histories of the vehicle yaw angle predicted in the FE simulations of the two NCHRP 350 crash tests showed good agreement with the corresponding test data. Additionally, the model was stable in crash simulations with the investigated range of pre-impact velocities, and both post-impact velocities and peak acceleration showed increasing trends with increasing impact velocities. This model could be used by safety researchers to investigate the performance of the ET-Plus end terminal in various crash scenarios and to investigate various possible design improvements of the end terminal and/or the front end of new vehicles.
Meng, YunzhuHu, WenUntaroiu, Costin Daniel
Influence of DISH, Ankylosis, Spondylosis and Osteophytes on Serious-to-Fatal Spinal Fractures and Cord Injury in Rear Impacts2019-01-10284/2/2019
Seats have become stronger over the past two decades and remain more upright in rear impacts. While head restraints are higher and more forward providing support for the head and neck, serious-to-fatal injuries to the thoracic and cervical spine have been seen in occupants with spinal disorders, such as DISH (diffuse idiopathic skeletal hyperostosis), ankylosis, spondylosis and/or osteophytes that ossify the joints in the spine. This case study addresses the influence of spinal disorders on fracture-dislocation and spinal cord injury in rear impacts with relatively upright seats. Nineteen field accidents were investigated where serious-to-fatal injuries of the thoracic and cervical spine occurred with the seat remaining upright or slightly reclined. The occupants were lap-shoulder belted, some with belt pretensioning and cinching latch plate. The occupants were older and had pre-existing disorders of the spine, including DISH, ankylosis, spondylosis and/or osteophytes that ossify the spinal joints. The crashes were summarized and the mechanism for injury was analyzed. The 19 cases involved fracture-dislocation and spinal cord injury at areas of the spine where DISH, ankylosis, spondylosis and/or osteophytes ossified the intervertebral soft tissues causing stiff and brittle joints that were vulnerable to fracture-dislocation by straightening of the spine. Published sled tests at 40 km/h (25 mph) with the 50th Hybrid III showed that peak chest acceleration was 13.5 ± 2.4 g (n=7) and head acceleration was 26.0 ± 12.0 g (n=8). Sled testing at 16 km/h (10 mph) with the BioRID IIg involved T1 x-accelerations of 12.6 ± 2.4 g (n=12) and head x-accelerations of 10.1 ± 0.2 g (n=12). These levels of acceleration are sufficient to fracture the calcified spine of the older occupants without ramping or moving off the support from the seatback and head restraint. A new injury mechanism for spinal fracture-dislocation is described in older occupants with spinal disorders. The occupant remains supported by the relatively upright seatback and high and forward head restraint. The accelerations that bring the occupant up to the delta V are sufficient to fracture-dislocate the calcified spine that tries to straighten in the crash.
Viano, DavidParenteau, ChantalWhite, Samuel
FRED II Quasistatic Seat Testing Rearward: An Improved Method Based on the SAE H-point Manikin2019-01-10324/2/2019
Various methods have been used to load a seat in the rear direction, including FMVSS 207, assorted body blocks and QST (quasistatic seat test). However, each method lacks some critical aspect of occupant loading of the seat or is too complex for routine development work. A new method is presented to determine the strength and energy transfer of a seat to an occupant in rear impacts that reflects how an occupant interacts with the seat in a rear impact. A metal-cast H-point manikin, called FRED II, was modified to support a loading bar and was pulled rearward into the seatback by a hydraulic ram. The force and displacement of the loading and the inboard and outboard seatback angle were measured. The response of the seat was recorded by video. The moment about the recliner pivot at peak force was determined by aligning the center of the recliner in side views of the seat position initially and at peak load. The height of the cable above the center of the recliner was determined giving the moment arm at peak load. The force was integrated with displacement to determine energy transfer to the seat. Twelve tests were performed with FRED II and twelve with a traditional body block used by CRA. There were nine matched tests with identical seats. With FRED II, the average peak moment was 2,407 ± 460 Nm and the energy transfer was 2,046 ± 531 J. With the body block, the average peak moment was 2,534 ± 297 Nm using the same method to determine the moment at peak force and the energy transfer was 1,740 ± 379 J. FRED II loads the seatback as the Hybrid III dummy does in sled tests. It measures the energy transfer capability of the seat in a manner that is similar to occupant loading in a rear impact. FRED II is a simple and improved quasistatic method for seat testing. FRED II provides the H-point location and can be used to measure head restraint position.
Viano, DavidBurnett, RogerWhite, Samuel
Analysis of Rear Seat Sled Tests with the 5th Female Hybrid III: Incorrect Conclusions in Bidez et al. SAE 2005-01-17082019-01-06184/2/2019
Objective: Sled test video and data were independently analyzed to assess the validity of statements and conclusions reported in Bidez et al. SAE paper 2005-01-1708 [7]. Method: An independent review and analysis of the test data and video was conducted for 9 sled tests at 35 km/h (21.5 mph). The 5th female Hybrid III was lap-shoulder belted in the 2nd or 3rd row seat of a SUV buck. For one series, the angle was varied from 0, 15, 30, 45 and 60 deg PDOF. The second series involved shoulder belt pretensioning and other belt modifications. Results: Bidez et al. [7] claimed “The lap belts moved up and over the pelvis of the small female dummy for all impact angles tested.” We found that there was no submarining in any of the tests with the production lap-shoulder belts. Bidez et al. [7] claimed “H3-5F dummies began to roll out of their shoulder belt at… 30 degrees. Complete loss of torso support was seen at 45 degrees without significant kinetic energy dissipation.” We found that the shoulder belt remained in place and restrained the upper torso in the 0, 15 and 30 deg sled tests. At 45 and 60 deg, significant restraint was provided before the belt slipped off the shoulder. It remained in contact with the arm and chest providing restraint. Bidez et al. [7] claimed “The results indicated kinematic movement of the dummies, which were predictive of injury in all sled runs.” We found that the kinematic control was good and the biomechanical responses were well below IARVs for the 5th female Hybrid III. Bidez et al. [7] claimed “a retractor pretensioner (7 ms fire time) eliminated both submarining and torso rollout in the H3-5F in the conditions tested.” We found that the pretensioner firing pulled the lap belt up onto the abdomen inducing submarining and causing abdominal loading in two out of four tests. Conclusion: The independent review of the videos and data shows that Bidez et al. [7] misstated the results, misrepresented the findings and reached incorrect conclusions on the testing.
Viano, DavidParenteau, Chantal
Evaluation of Harness Tightening Procedures for Child Restraint System (CRS) Sled Testing2019-01-06174/2/2019
Sled testing procedures should reflect a rigorous level of repeatability across trials and reproducibility across testing facilities. Currently, different testing facilities use various methods to set the harness tension for child restraint system (CRS) sled tests. The objective of this study is to identify which harness tightening procedure(s) produce tensions within a reasonable target range while showing adequate reproducibility, repeatability, and ease-of-use. Five harness tightening procedures were selected: A) FMVSS 213 procedure, B) a 3-prong tension gauge, C) ECE R44/R129 procedure, D) two finger method, and E) pinch test. Two CRS models were instrumented with a tension load cell in the harness system. Seven sled room operators were recruited to perform each of the five harness tightening procedures for ten repetitions apiece on both instrumented CRS using a Hybrid III 3-year-old. The static harness tension measured by the load cell was recorded after each procedure was completed. Data were analyzed for mean, variance, reproducibility, and repeatability. Operator feedback surveys were used to quantify ease-of-use. The ECE R44/R129 procedure produced harness tensions which were quite low. The two finger procedure produced the highest tensions while the 3-prong tension gauge, pinch test, and FMVSS 213 procedures produced mid-level tensions. Poor repeatability was apparent for all five harness tightening procedures. The FMVSS 213 method ranked lowest for ease-of-use. Operators preferred using the 3-prong gauge, two finger method, and pinch test. The load cell readings were sensitive to the order and direction in which the operators adjusted the harness components. High amounts of friction within the harness might prevent it from acting as a homogeneous, continuous system. Sequential tightening of the various sections of harness and/or monitoring the tension at multiple locations might be valuable.
Mansfield, JulieBaker, GretchenBolte, John
Head and Neck Loading Conditions over a Decade of IIHS Rear Impact Seat Testing2019-01-12274/2/2019
Rear-end impacts are the most common crash scenario in the United States. Although automated vehicle (AV) technologies, such as frontal crash warning (FCW) and automatic emergency braking (AEB), are mitigating and preventing rear-end impacts, the technology is only gradually being introduced and currently has only limited effectiveness. Accordingly, there is a need to evaluate the current state of passive safety technologies, including the performance of seatbacks and head restraints. The objective of this study was to examine trends in head and neck loading during rear impact testing in new vehicle models over the prior decade. Data from 601 simulated rear impact sled tests (model years 2004 to 2018) conducted as a part of the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) Vehicle Seat/Head Restraint Evaluation Protocol were obtained. This dynamic evaluation involves a simulated rear-end crash using a Biofidelic Rear Impact (BioRID IIg) ATD positioned in the seat attached to a crash simulation sled and accelerated to represent a rear crash with a delta-V of approximately 15.6 kph (15.6 ± 0.26 kph). Head and neck injury metrics were calculated for all tests to evaluate trends in the test ATD responses across model years. Reductions in HIC 15, Nij, and upper neck tensile forces were observed across all model years. Nkm, upper neck flexion moments, extension moments, and shear forces were found to show little or no change by model year. Reductions in time to initial contact with the head restraint were observed and likely contributed to reduced head accelerations and neck tensile forces. Given the anticipated persistence of rear-end impacts and potential changes to the vehicle interior layout with improving AV technology, the data should be considered by designers, researchers, and evaluators looking to project future crash and injury rates in rear-end impacts.
Scanlon, John M.Isaacs, JessicaGarman, Christina
Risk of Concussion in Low- to Moderate-Speed Frontal and Rear-End Motor Vehicle Collisions Evaluated Using Head Acceleration-Based Metrics2019-01-12184/2/2019
Over the past decade, there has been an increase in awareness and concern about the occurrence and long-term effects of concussions. Traumatic brain injury (TBI)-related emergency department (ED) visits associated with motor vehicle collisions, including patients with a diagnosis of concussion or mild TBI (mTBI), have increased while deaths and hospital admissions related to TBI have decreased. The diagnostic criteria for concussion have evolved and broadened, and based on current assessments and diagnostic imaging techniques, there are often no objective findings, yet a diagnosis of concussion may still be rendered. Clinical assessment of concussion may be based only on patient-reported symptoms and history, making it difficult to objectively relate the reported increase in TBI-related ED visits due to motor vehicle collisions to specific collision parameters. This study aims to perform a scientific evaluation of concussion risk during motor vehicle collisions, strengthened by objective, quantitative data, specifically focusing on head acceleration-based metrics. Data from full-scale passenger vehicle crash tests are reported for frontal and rear-end collisions with delta-Vs ranging from 6.0 to 19.0 kph (3.7 to 11.8 mph) and 5.6 to 19.5 kph (3.5 to 12.1 mph), respectively. Head linear and rotational kinematic data were recorded from instrumented Hybrid III 50th percentile male anthropomorphic test devices (ATDs) restrained in the driver’s seats. Several acceleration-based metrics currently used to assess risk of concussion were calculated and compared to published injury risk relationships that have been developed from field accident data, human subjects, and biomechanical models. Overall, the magnitudes of acceleration were low and the injury metrics corresponded to a negligible risk of concussion in these low- to moderate-speed collisions.
Pasquesi, Stephanie A.Bruno, AlexanderCourtney, AmyImler, Stacy M.Smedley, JaninePrange, Michael T.
Evaluation of Occupant Loading in Low- to Moderate-Speed Frontal and Rear-End Motor Vehicle Collisions2019-01-12204/2/2019
Low- to moderate-speed motor vehicle collisions are common roadway occurrences that are generally associated with low rates of reported injury. While such complaints are generally infrequent, claims of injuries resulting from low- to moderate-speed motor vehicle collisions persist. A limited body of literature using quantitative techniques and full-scale crash tests is available to assess the injury potential associated with such collisions. Prior studies have analyzed occupant kinematics and kinetics as well as human injury risk in low- to moderate-speed collisions with older vehicle vintages but do not assess the effects of updated vehicle interior designs and occupant protection devices reflective of efforts to optimize occupant kinematics and reduce occupant loading and injury risk in more modern vehicles. This study was conducted to evaluate the injury potential for occupants of vehicles with modern design elements involved in low- to moderate-speed inline motor vehicle collisions. We expected to find that occupants in modern vehicles would demonstrate low potential for injury in such collisions. Four full-scale inline (collinear) crash tests were conducted to assess occupant loading during frontal and rear-end impacts. The vehicles used in each test were instrumented late-model, mid-sized sedans of the same make and model occupied by restrained and instrumented Hybrid III 50th-percentile male anthropomorphic test devices (ATDs). The tests involved aligned front-to-rear bumper collisions at closing speeds ranging from 7.4 kph to 33.6 kph (4.6 mph to 20.9 mph). Kinetic data collected from the instrumented ATDs were evaluated to assess the biomechanical loading environment throughout the crash pulse in both the striking (bullet) and struck (target) vehicles. Evaluation of the occupant responses established that the loads and moments generated during these low- to moderate-speed collisions were far less than accepted injury assessment reference values (IARVs). Furthermore, the recorded spinal loads demonstrated characteristics of inertial loading with similar timescales as common daily activities and, in many cases, were of magnitudes less than or comparable to loads generated by volunteers performing volitional and non-injurious activities.
Toney-Bolger, MeganCampbell, IanMiller, BruceDavis, MathieuFisher, Jacob
Innovative Knee Airbag (KAB) Concept for Small Overlap and Oblique Frontal Impacts2019-01-06214/2/2019
Considerable research has been conducted in terms of attempting to reduce lower leg injury risk in full frontal impacts, in some cases by the use of a knee airbag (KAB). However, there has been limited research into the performance of KAB systems during a crash test with increased oblique loading, such as the IIHS small overlap frontal test, an oblique moving deformable barrier test (OI) being researched by NHTSA, and a mobile progressive deformable barrier test (MPDB) that is expected to be implemented by Euro NCAP in the next few years. The objective of the current numerical study was concentrated on the evaluation of an innovative KAB concept design intended to reduce ATD right inboard lower leg/foot responses under small overlap and oblique loading conditions. A novel appendage KAB concept design was developed with the help of morphing and computational studies which were performed with different ATD sizes. In the study, one of the lower leg/foot responses was monitored and compared over a conventional KAB design. Cases investigated in the study showed that the novel appendage KAB concept design acts as a conventional KAB in full frontal impact modes (similar right inboard femur responses) and has the potential to reduce right inboard lower leg/foot responses by an average 16% (small overlap impact mode) and 20% (oblique impact mode) over the conventional KAB design. Furthermore, it was noted that the novel design could potentially be adapted to achieve targeted right inboard lower leg responses in full, offset and oblique frontal crash tests with minimal impact on the left outboard responses.
Makwana, RahulJindal, Pardeep
Passenger Vehicle Dynamic Response and Characterization of Side Structure during Low- to Moderate-Speed Side Impacts2019-01-04204/2/2019
A significant portion of real-world passenger vehicle side impacts occur at lower speeds than testing conducted by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) or the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS). Test data from low- to moderate-speed side impacts involving late-model passenger vehicles is limited, making the evaluation of vehicle impact response, occupant loading, and injury potential challenging. This study provides the results of low- to moderate-speed impact testing involving a late-model mid-size sedan. Two full-scale Non-Deformable Moving Barrier (NDMB) side impact crash tests were conducted at speeds of 6.2 mph (10.0 kph) and 13.4 mph (21.6 kph). Instrumentation on the late-model sedan used for the test series included tri-axis accelerometers and seat belt load cells. In both tests, instrumented Hybrid III 50th percentile-male Anthropomorphic Test Devices (ATDs) were restrained in the driver and passenger seats using the standard three-point seat belts. Response data for the vehicle, barrier, and ATDs was recorded using onboard data acquisition, and on- and off-board real-time and high-speed video cameras. In addition, the deformation to the side of the sedan was quantified from pre- and post-test laser scan data. Results from the test series provided data regarding accelerations, velocity change, and restitution. The damage to the side structure of the vehicle was assessed and conclusions regarding damage initiation and damage progression are discussed. Conservation of Momentum and Conservation of Energy analyses are presented and force-displacement characteristics and energy dissipation were evaluated and compared. Utilizing the data that was developed from the test series, vehicle side stiffness modeling was also conducted.
Skiera, JasonCrosby, CharlesBare, CleveParadiso, MarcCampbell, Gregory
Evaluation of Occupant Kinematics in Low- to Moderate-Speed Frontal and Rear-End Motor Vehicle Collisions2019-01-12264/2/2019
Low- to moderate-speed motor vehicle collisions are a common crash type and are sometimes associated with injury complaints. Understanding occupant motion (kinematics) in response to low- and moderate-speed motor vehicle collisions is important for evaluating occupant interactions with interior vehicle structures, including the restraint systems, with the ultimate goal of assessing injury potential. Furthermore, quantitative occupant kinematic data from full-scale crash testing of late-model passenger vehicles is limited for collisions at low- to moderate-speeds. The current study reports kinematic data from full-scale frontal and rear-end crash tests of late-model, mid-size sedans with delta-Vs ranging from 6.0 to 19.0 kph (3.7 to 11.8 mph) and 5.6 to 19.5 kph (3.5 to 12.1 mph), respectively. For each test vehicle, the motion of a Hybrid III 50th-percentile male anthropomorphic test device (ATD) restrained in the driver seat was recorded using high-speed onboard video. Motion tracking of the video was used to evaluate the excursion and velocity of each ATD’s head, shoulder, elbow, and knee with respect to the vehicle interior. Restraint loads were recorded via load cells placed on the driver’s torso and lap belts. For both the frontal and rear-end collisions, the maximum excursion and velocity of the ATD with respect to the occupant compartment generally increased with increasing delta-V. During the occupant rebound phase of the rear-end collisions, the maximum excursion and velocity of the ATD also generally increased with increasing delta-V and was generally less than its initial rearward excursion and velocity.
Bruno, AlexanderToney-Bolger, MeganGeorge, JuffKoller, JeffreyFilatov, AntonOlberding, Joseph
The Kinematic Analysis of Occupant Excursions and Accelerations during Staged Low Speed Far-Side Lateral Vehicle-to-Vehicle Impacts2019-01-10304/2/2019
The collection of research regarding occupant kinematics during low speed lateral vehicle-to-vehicle impacts is far less comprehensive than the much larger body of literature that quantifies the occupant kinematics associated with low speed rear end (longitudinal) impacts. In order to augment the available data, a series of 39 low speed far-side lateral vehicle-to-vehicle impacts were conducted in a laboratory setting. A combination of accelerometers and 3D motion tracking was used to characterize the motions of both the Target and Bullet vehicles during their collisions. The Target vehicle was initially stationary; the Bullet vehicle impacted the Target vehicle at the front passenger side door. The Bullet vehicle pre-impact speeds across all tests ranged from approximately 2.5 to 5.5 mph (4.0 to 8.9 kph; 1.1 to 2.5 m/s). Eight volunteers participated in the study. Volunteers were seated in the driver seat during the impacts and were outfitted with accelerometers on their head and wore reflective markers for 3D motion tracking on the left side of their body. The experimental design included conducting lateral impacts while the volunteers were in both “non-distracted” and “distracted” states to identify any potential influence on occupant kinematics. In addition, effects of gender and anthropometry were explored. Primary outcome measures that were analyzed for each lateral impact included occupant accelerations measured at the head and the lateral displacement of the head relative to its initial position prior to impact. Volunteer peak resultant head accelerations (including gravity) ranged from 1.90 to 4.32 g. The peak Y-axis displacement of the head relative to the Target vehicle and away from the driver side B-pillar was 3.86 to 12.16 inches (9.80 to 30.89 cm) while the peak Y-axis displacement of the head relative to the Target vehicle and toward the driver side B-pillar ranged from 0.02 to 7.34 inches (0.05 to 18.64 cm). In all trials, the head displacement toward the driver side B-pillar was insufficient to cause physical contact.
Shibata, PeggyRoberts, JuliusSprague, JamesLight, AlysonStegemann, JacobMeza-Arroyo, ManuelCapser, Shawn
Validation of Crush Energy Calculation Methods for Use in Accident Reconstructions by Finite Element Analysis09-06-02-000910/4/2018
The crush energy is a key parameter to determine the delta-V in accident reconstructions. Since an accurate car crush profile can be obtained from 3D scanners, this research aims at validating the methods currently used in calculating crush energy from a crush profile. For this validation, a finite element (FE) car model was analyzed using various types of impact conditions to investigate the theory of energy-based accident reconstruction. Two methods exist to calculate the crush energy: the work based on the barrier force and the work based on force calculated by the vehicle acceleration times the vehicle mass. We show that the crush energy calculated from the barrier force was substantially larger than the internal energy calculated from the FE model. Whereas the crush energy calculated from the vehicle acceleration was comparable to the internal energy of the FE model. In full frontal impact simulations, the energy of approach factor (EAF) has a linear relation with the residual crush, which had been validated in previous experimental studies. In our study using FE analysis, we found that the slope of EAF versus the residual crush was comparable with that of the dynamic crush energy versus the dynamic crush for crashes at 55 km/h. Using this slope and the residual crush from a 55 km/h impact test, the slope and the intercept of the EAF vs. residual crush can be determined using only one crash test. A database of the slopes and the intercepts was made using Japan New Car Assessment Program (JNCAP) tests. In offset impact simulations, the crush energy calculated from the crush profile agreed with the internal energy of the car FE model when at least one front rail was involved. In oblique impacts, the correction factor for crush energy is not necessary within 20 degrees of principal direction of force of the car’s longitudinal axis.
Numata, ShusukeMizuno, KojiIto, DaisukeOkumura, Dai
Predictive Estimation of Side Pole Impact Dummy Response Based on Linear Impactor SAB Performance2018-01-50186/18/2018
This article discusses steps to predictively estimate the responses of Anthropomorphic Test Device (ATD) in a side impact event, based on a Side Airbag (SAB) Force-Deformation (F-D) characteristics derived from the linear impactor test. A critical load management challenge that has been used to assess this predictive response process is the oblique pole impact test - part of the FMVSS 214 protocol. In this scenario, the ATD is assumed to have a free travel until it is stopped by the crushed and stacked up door against the rigid pole. Three critical energy management paths involved to manage the kinetic energy of the ATD at impact are assumed at the onset, namely, the door trim crush, ATD torso loading and most important efficient energy management of the SAB at a controlled force level. The SAB energy management is assumed critical and tied with the final response of the test ATD. In the study being reported, the amount of energy absorbed by the SAB and the reaction force of the SAB are used to predictively estimate the final responses of the test ATD. After robust vehicle components and systems designs for body structure, door trim, friendly interior and effective SAB to ATD coverage are achieved, results from this study show that the F-D response of the SAB is crucial and may be used to predictively estimate the final response of the test ATD. The ability to predictively estimate ATD responses via linear impactor derived SAB F-D at the component level will invariably greatly reduce SAB development time and overall side impact safety development cost. Examples of physical SAB linear impactor test results have been used to demonstrate the effectiveness of this predictive assessment tool in terms of SAB development time.
Uduma, KaluPurushothaman, DipuWu, JianpingBeaudet, BrianKeshtkar, Hamid
Development of Component Level Transfer Equations of Simplified Human and ATD Occupant Models09-06-01-00056/5/2018
Safety systems have historically been evaluated with anthropomorphic test devices for research, development, or regulatory concerns. Human body models are another avenue for use in the investigation of occupant safety. In this study, transfer equations are developed to quantify the response of a human model (Global Human Body Models Consortium average male simplified model) and dummy model (Hybrid-III) in equivalent environments. Environments were selected based on certification test setups used for the Hybrid III ATD as well as a basic frontal sled environment. The tests include a head drop, neck flexion/extension, and chest and knee impacts. Furthermore, models were positioned within a simplified occupant interior for sled tests. In all, 30 matched pair simulations were run, 60 in total. Peak metrics between human and anthropomorphic test device models showed strong linear correlation in component testing however, as the complexity of the simulations increased, agreement tended to decrease. Kinematic data are also presented and they trend similarly between human and anthropomorphic test device models however they exhibit different timing and peaks. Within the range tested, the developed transfer equations can be used to estimate performance of one model if data from the other is available. Furthermore, the evaluation of risk for these equivalent impacts is provided for HIC-15, max chest deflections and femur forces aggregated across all tests. Over the range tested, equivalent impacts result in roughly equivalent risk levels with the exception of the femur, which resulted in higher forces in the Hybrid III and thus predicted higher risk.
Guleyupoglu, BerkanKoya, BharathGayzik, Francis Scott
Modeling the Effect of Foam Density and Strain Rate on the Compressive Response of Polyurethane Foams05-11-02-00145/8/2018
Due to the high deformability and energy dissipation capacity of polymer foams in compression, they are used in automotive applications to mitigate mechanical impacts. The mechanical response of the foams is strongly affected by their density. Phenomenological relations have been proposed to describe the effect of foam density on their stress-strain response in compression at a fixed loading rate and the effect of loading rate at a fixed foam density. In the present work, these empirical approaches are combined allowing for the dependence of loading rate effect in compression on foam density. The minimum experimental data set for calibration of the proposed model consists of compression test results at two different loading rates of foams with two different densities. Rigid closed-cell polyurethane foams with apparent density in the range of ca. 100 to 300 kg/m3 have been produced and tested in compression up to a ca. 80% engineering strain at low (0.00167 to 0.5 s−1) and intermediate (~102 s−1) strain rates. The model parameters were evaluated from test results of the largest and smallest-density foams at low loading rates, differing by two orders of magnitude. The relative root mean square error of stress prediction for intermediate foam densities was found to range from ca. 6 to 12% at low strain rates and reach up to 34% at the higher strain rate. The proposed approach for modeling of foam behavior is expected to be useful in preliminary design of structural parts with impact mitigation functionality.
Japins, GuntisKalnins, KasparsKirpluks, MikelisCabulis, Ugis
Truck and Sport Utility Vehicle Front End Stiffness Corridors2018-01-05184/3/2018
The purpose of this study was to characterize front stiffness response of contemporary sport utility vehicles (SUVs) and trucks. Vehicle front impact test data were obtained from data published by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration [NHTSA]. For all tests, force data were obtained from barrier load cells and stroke data were derived from accelerometers. Data from 53 truck and SUV tests were aggregated by vehicle product segment according to body style to obtain mean ± standard deviation (SD) stiffness corridors: (1) compact unibody SUV/crossover, (2) small unibody SUV/crossover, (3) mid-size unibody SUV/crossover, (4) frame SUV, and (5) frame truck. To compare between vehicle product segments, this study also considered the average stiffness (slope) within the stroke region required to achieve 300 kN total barrier force. Across unibody SUV segments, average stiffness varied from 1.4–1.8 kN/mm. Stiffness of frame SUVs and trucks was up to 93% higher than stiffness of unibody SUVs (2.7 vs. 1.4 kN/mm). Observed differences in stiffness corridors may have been due in part to unibody SUV design differences. For example, additional stroke (structure) was observed forward of the front axle comparing an exemplar mid-size SUV and frame SUV. In some cases, this structure may include a low stiffness bumper absorber. When stiffness corridors were offset to simulate a low stiffness initial geometry, better agreement between mean stiffness corridors was observed across vehicle segments. As unibody SUVs may continue to replace frame designs, future work should confirm directly the reasons for this stiffness difference in vehicle segments.
Hallman, JasonBuck, JessicaHam, Suk Jae
Finite Element Analysis to Analyze the Properties of Pole Impacts2018-01-05194/3/2018
The objectives of this study were to use Finite Element (FE) simulations to predict the crush profile resulting from frontal pole impacts and to compare the results of the FE simulations to existing reconstruction methods. A 2001 Ford Taurus FE model created by the National Crash Analysis Center (NCAC) was used to simulate four pole impact tests performed by the Insurance Institute of Highway Safety (IIHS) involving the same generation of Ford Taurus. The FE crush profiles show good correlation to the physical tests. The maximum crush was predicted within ±3% for three of the tests and was under predicted by 7% in the fourth test. The same FE model was then used to simulate 22 more pole impacts to study how impact speed and lateral pole offset from the centerline affected maximum crush. At impact speeds of 32 km/h, the maximum crush did not vary by more than 4 cm for different pole locations ±500 mm from the vehicle centerline. For impact speeds of 48 and 64 km/h, maximum crush increased with increased lateral pole offset. At speeds of 48 to 64 km/h and pole locations between ±272 mm from the vehicle centerline, the CRASH3 method predicted impact speeds within ±5% of the simulated crashes. At speeds of 32 to 64 km/h and pole locations between ±272-mm from the vehicle centerline, the Craig (1996) method predicted impact speeds within ±8% of the simulated crashes.
Gish, RussellFix, Ryan
Eleven Instrumented Motorcycle Crash Tests and Development of Updated Motorcycle Impact-Speed Equations2018-01-05174/3/2018
Eleven instrumented crash tests were performed as part of the 2016 World Reconstruction Exposition (WREX2016), using seven Harley-Davidson motorcycles and three automobiles. For all tests, the automobile was stationary while the motorcycle was delivered into the vehicle, while upright with tires rolling, at varying speeds. Seven tests were performed at speeds between 30 and 46 mph while four low-speed tests were performed to establish the onset of permanent motorcycle deformation. Data from these tests, and other published testing, was analyzed using available models to determine their accuracy when predicting the impact speed of Harley-Davidson motorcycles. The most accurate model was the Modified Eubanks set of equations introduced in 2009, producing errors with an average of 0.4 mph and a standard deviation (SD) of 4.8 mph. An updated set of Eubanks-style equations were developed adding data published since 2009, and advancing from two equations (pillars/axles and doors/fenders) to four equations (axles, pillars/bumpers, doors, and fenders). When applied to the subject tests, the newly developed set of equations produced an average error of 3.5 mph (SD = 4.3 mph). With respect to all available data (N = 99), the equations produced an average error of 0.1 mph and a standard deviation of 5.8 mph. The errors were also analyzed for each of the four equations developed here, and confidence intervals offered. This research, which represents the first detailed analysis of Harley-Davidson motorcycles’ collision response, indicates they behave in a manner similar to previously tested motorcycles. Further, the equations developed and presented here give accident investigators a refined method for estimating the impact speed of an upright motorcycle, Harley-Davidson or otherwise, having struck an automobile with its front tire.
Peck, LouisManning, JosephBartlett, WadeDickerson, CharlesDeyerl, Eric
Analysis and Simulation of Low-Speed Collision of Car Front Bumpers2018-01-14604/3/2018
Bumper systems are vital to improving automotive passive safety and reducing the maintenance cost in low-speed collision. Automotive companies need to develop bumpers with adequate strength, high energy absorption rate, minimum weight and least expense. To shorten the product development period and lower the development cost, four evaluation conditions were proposed to assess the behaviors of car front bumpers based on the three main low-speed collision regulations of the US Part 581, the Canadian CFVSS215 and the European ECE-R42. A finite element method was put forward to model the car front bumper and to analyze the low-speed collision performance of the bumper system. A drop hammer impact test was carried out to verify the validity of the method, and experiment results indicated the correctness of the finite element model. The dynamic response and the energy absorption parameters of the bumper system were calculated, including structural deformation, collision force and energy absorption ratio. The maximum longitudinal deformation and the energy absorption ratio were chosen as the evaluation standards to determine whether the bumper meets the collision requirement or not. The influence of beam thickness on the collision performance of the bumper was also discussed, and a two-mm-thick beam was adopted after comparison.
Li, MinXia, ZhangyangShangguan, Wenbin
Items per page:
1 – 50 of 738