Browse Topic: Aerodynamics
Helicopter tail shake constitutes a significant limitation to both passenger comfort and aircraft stability. Under powered descent conditions, elevated Angle of Attack (AoA) cause flow separation around the rotor hub and engine cowling, leading to the development of an unsteady wake dominated by large-scale turbulent structures. To support the helicopter tail shake phenomenon investigation, a dedicated Particle Image Velocimetry (PIV) experimental setup was designed in this work, together with four aerodynamic devices aimed at mitigating tail shake. These components were then tested through a wind tunnel campaign with the PIV setup. The proposed aerodynamic components were conceived to either deflect the hub wake away from the tail empennages or to decrease the Turbulent Kinetic Energy (TKE) within the wake. To achieve these objectives, a dorsal fin, a horse-collar, and two spoiler configurations inspired by automotive applications were designed and experimentally evaluated. The devices were tested both as standalone solutions and in combined arrangements on a scaled helicopter wind tunnel model featuring a rotating hub and blade shanks. The vertical velocity component, was used as an indicator of wake deflection, and the Turbulent Kinetic Energy was used as an indicator of wake turbulence. The Horse Collar and the Large Spoiler showed a reduction in both indicators suggesting possible tail shake mitigating capabilities, and additional improvements were achieved when the two devices were deployed in combination.
In this study, a multifidelity aeroelastic framework is presented for predicting trim conditions in rotary-wing aircraft, with the main focus placed on the DUST implementation and its application to helicopters and quadrotors. The methodology combines aerodynamic and structural solvers of different fidelity, specifically DUST and the multibody dynamics solver MBDyn, through the preCICE coupling interface to enable direct comparison with rigid and coupled aeroelastic solutions. The trim problem is formulated from the six degree of freedom rigid body equilibrium equations in a helical turn reference frame, naturally covering both steady and maneuvering flight. Although the same formulation can be extended to fixed-wing configurations, the present paper is focused on rotorcraft applications. The framework is first applied to the SA330 Puma helicopter, chosen for the availability of validated flight test data. The methodology is then extended to a multirotor derived from a NASA quadrotor, demonstrating that the same trim strategy can be transferred to distributed-lift rotorcraft. Results highlight the potential of the proposed approach to provide physically consistent and computationally affordable predictions of helicopter and multirotor equilibrium states.
NASA's successful demonstration of powered flight on Mars through the Ingenuity Helicopter, as part of the Mars 2020 Perseverance rover mission, has led to the development of next generation Martian rotorcraft. The future of Martian rotorcraft has evolved to include high payload-carrying vehicles to possibly contribute to planetary science missions, which will require improved flight dynamics and rotor aerodynamic performance to fly at nominally high forward flight speeds and at higher flight altitudes. To ensure the feasibility and viability of successful mission performance, it is also critical to mature the structural design for advanced Martian rotorcraft to bridge the gap between the best practices of the spacecraft and aircraft communities. This paper focuses on the structural analysis of a Mars Science Helicopter (MSH) blade using finite element methods. Multiple loading conditions including launch and operational flight were applied to investigate the blade’s structural integrity. The blade’s modal natural frequencies were also analyzed to investigate the blade's dynamic behavior.
RPM-controlled hexacopters offer mechanical simplicity and inherent redundancy, but are unable to re-trim under all failure cases in forward flight. This paper investigates the use of reverse-enabled rotors as a means of expanding the attainable trim envelope and improving fault tolerance in RPM-controlled hexacopters. Isolated rotor experiments are conducted to characterize thrust and torque behavior under forward and reverse rotation, providing validation data for aerodynamic modeling. A blade-element-based model implemented in the Rensselaer Multicopter Analysis Code (RMAC) is then used to perform comprehensive trim analyses for a 1200-lb-class hexacopter in hover and in cruise at the best-range speed of 65 kts. Post-failure trim solutions are evaluated for four configurations, including edge-first and vertex-first orientations with different rotor spin directions. Results show that enabling reverse rotation allows trim recovery for all single-rotor failure cases in cruise, including aft-rotor failures that are not trimmable with conventional RPM-controlled rotors. A systematic comparison of peak rotor torque, peak rotor power, and total aircraft power reveals that failure severity is governed primarily by yaw moment deficits arising from the combined loss of hub torque and aerodynamic drag. Among the configurations examined, the edge-first configuration with a counter-clockwise spinning rotor 1 exhibits the lowest rotor torque and rotor power requirements, post-failure.
An experimental investigation was conducted to characterize the effects of partial-ground on the aerodynamics of a hovering rotor. A model-scale rotor was tested at a range of heights above ground and under partial-ground coverage, and rotor hub forces and moments were measured using a six-axis force/torque transducer during constant-power operation. The measurements were used to develop a semi-empirical thrust ratio model that accurately captures trends from out-of-ground effect to full-ground effect conditions. This model predicts realistic thrust behavior at low ground-coverage conditions, exhibiting high adjusted R2 and minimal root mean square error. Time-resolved particle image velocimetry was conducted for selected cases to examine induced flow features and to qualitatively assess changes in the downwash and edge-driven crossflow associated with partial-ground interactions. A geometric rotor-ground interaction area based on a circular-segment formulation was correlated to the thrust coefficient over the interacting region. Results show that thrust increases with ground coverage and decreases with increasing out-of-ground height, whereas moment coefficients increase with decreasing height. The increases in thrust and moment can be attributed to a reduction in the induced velocity above ground, as observed in the measured flow field, thereby increasing the effective ground-induced pressure beneath the rotor.
This paper discusses the design of a 2000-lb manned eVTOL aircraft propelled by a novel cycloidal rotor propulsion system. To systematically evaluate the performance of the proposed configuration, a coupled trim model was developed to quantitatively evaluate the performance of the configuration across a range of forward flight speeds. The trim framework integrates an efficient physics-guided neural-network-based aerodynamic model for cycloidal rotor performance with a vehicle-level dynamic response model. This framework is used to conduct a systematic parametric study to identify key cycloidal rotor and airframe design parameters. The selected configuration is verified using high-fidelity CFD simulations, and a detailed structural design, powertrain design, and CAD model of the aircraft is developed. In addition to CFD validation, the proposed cycloidal rotor underwent structural optimization to confirm the validity of such a concept at this scale. The results demonstrate that the cycloidal rotors provide a viable propulsion alternative for eVTOL aircraft with strong potential to overcome limitations of existing configurations.
Dimensional reduction of data can be accomplished through various methods and has applications critical to machine learning and surrogate modeling. Within the rotorcraft community, leveraging these techniques allows for improved rotor parameterization and performance prediction. Machine learning models generally perform faster and better with lower input dimensions, so long as all necessary information is retained, making appropriate dimension reduction paramount. Data can also be arranged in a one-dimensional (concatenated/stacked) or two-dimensional arrays to take advantage of function correlations, and this arrangement may allow for greater reduction at lower reconstruction costs. Principal Component Analysis with a stacked input shape proves to be the most effective reduction method considered, with reconstruction accuracy being validated though a suite of mid-fidelity aerodynamic simulations. A blade geometry defined using 204 original parameters can be fully described using just 10 component parameters with the reconstructed blade maintaining performance figures within 1% of the original blade.
An experimental investigation was conducted to explore the loads, acoustics, and tip vortex trajectories of coaxial counter-rotating (CCR) rotor with unequal upper and lower radii. The upper and lower rotor radii were tested both at the nominal radius of 1.108 m, and also with a lower rotor radius of 90% nominal radius, for a constant rotor speed of 1180 RPM and a constant inter-rotor spacing of z/R = 0.108. Rotors were torque balanced and tested for a range of upper rotor collective pitch from -2◦ to 10◦ . The power required for both CCR systems was within 0.9% for most trim conditions, and equal thrust was produced at upper rotor collectives of 6◦ and 8◦ (within 1.0%). At low loading conditions the unequal radii configuration produced more thrust for the same power due to a reduction in profile drag. The overall sound pressure level (OASPL) was lower for the CCR rotor with shortened lower rotor blades at all angles of elevation. Larger reductions in A-weighted OASPL(A) were observed, due to a larger contribution of broadband noise to the total OASPL(A).
A technique for rapidly designing roughness tolerant low drag airfoils has been developed. Airfoils of varying thickness to chord ratio, ranging from 10% to 22% have been designed. A target pressure distribution is specified by the designer for a notional lift coefficient, Reynolds number, and Mach number. The specified pressure distribution is first analyzed using classical integral boundary layer analyses and empirical transition criteria for smooth and rough airfoils to ensure laminar flow over much of the airfoil under design conditions. The resulting airfoil is subsequently analyzed under natural transition, and forced transition caused by the tripping of the boundary layer due to roughness near the leading edge. It is found that the present approach performs well for a broad range of lift coefficients. An in-house propeller design and analysis tool has been used to examine the impact of the low drag airfoil on the pusher propeller performance designed for a fixed wing UAV drone configuration.
This paper presents the design and validation of the Rotor Optimization for the Advancement of Mars eXploration (ROAMX) Hover Test Stand, a vacuum compatible stand developed to measure rotor performance under Mars aerodynamic conditions. The stand integrates a high-speed water-cooled motor, a variable pitch hub, and a structural safety system capable of withstanding the high loads resulting from rotor blade loss while enabling continued experimental operations. The stand also maintains the measurement fidelity required for thrust and torque characterization at low Reynolds number. Aerodynamic blockage was limited to less than 20% through geometric constraints on the stand architecture. Calibration and sensor procedures ensured correct load transfer through the intended structural load path and also verified sensor accuracy. Test Entry 1 demonstrated successful test stand performance and testing of experimental blades. The stand spun blades to 4,000 Revolutions per Minute (RPM) for Test Entry 1, but the motor is capable of continuous operation at 5,900 RPM. The ROAMX Hover Test Stand provides a reusable experimental capability that enables high-fidelity evaluation of Mars rotor designs.
Recent flight tests and simulations have suggested that the outwash from eVTOL air-taxis could be larger than conventional helicopters of equal weight and thus pose greater safety issues for their operation than previously anticipated. This has prompted interest in the analytical and experimental study of the aerodynamics related to multi-rotor aircraft outwash. This paper will describe work investigating some of the related issues, specifically (1) how wake models and wake model parameters impact outwash predictions in comprehensive rotorcraft analyses and (2) considerations when scaling results from model scale to full scale. This work will also compare outwash predictions for conventional and multi-rotor VTOL aircraft obtained with a Lagrangian free-vortex wake model and with an Eulerian velocity-vorticity grid based wake model.
Achieving noise reduction in rotorcraft requires an analysis of various design parameters and flight conditions. However, high-fidelity methods are computationally expensive. To overcome this limitation, reduced order model (ROM)-based surrogate models have been applied to aerodynamics and aeroacoustics prediction. This study proposes a ROM-based surrogate model employing a variational autoencoder (VAE) to predict rotor aerodynamic loads and associated noise. Train and test datasets were generated using reformulated vortex particle method across a wide range of flight conditions. The proposed framework was applied to a single rotor, and its performance was evaluated qualitatively and quantitively in comparison with proper orthogonal decomposition (POD)-based surrogate model. The results show that VAE-based model consistently outperformed the POD model in noise prediction. These results demonstrate that the proposed framework enables accurate rotor noise prediction under various flight conditions and provides a promising approach for low-noise rotorcraft design and operational planning.
A high-fidelity computational study is conducted to investigate the aerodynamic behavior and flight response of an electric Vertical Take-Off and Landing (eVTOL) multirotor configuration using unsteady computational fluid dynamics (CFD) framework. Four simulation cases are considered to examine the vehicle aerodynamics under both prescribed and fully coupled conditions. Prescribed hover and forward-flight cases isolate rotor aerodynamics and rotor-airframe interactions under constrained kinematics. Six-degree-of-freedom (6-DoF) free-flight maneuvering simulations capture the coupled evolution of aerodynamic loads, vehicle attitude, and translational motion. The results demonstrate that the high-fidelity unsteady CFD framework, coupled with rigid-body dynamics, effectively resolves the tightly coupled aerodynamic–dynamic interactions inherent to eVTOL configurations. This work provides a foundation for future investigations into trim strategies, control modeling, and expanded flight envelopes.
The Rotor Blown Wing (RBW) is a tailsitter Vertical Takeoff and Landing (VTOL) Unmanned Aerial System (UAS) configuration that leverages cutting-edge autonomous flight controls through Sikorsky's MATRIX™ technology to create a highly capable, efficient, and scalable technology platform. By combining the benefits of fixed- and rotary-wing aircraft, the RBW configuration eliminates the need for traditional UAS launch and recovery infrastructure. This paper describes the RBW-5 prototype, a 100-pound, dual 5-foot diameter proprotor demonstrator, and discusses the comprehensive evaluation of its design and operability through a combination of flight tests, wind tunnel experiments, and computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations. The results demonstrate the maturity of the UAS and highlights key accomplishments of the RBW-5 program, including successful autonomous takeoff and landing and transitions between hover and forward flight, the extraction of critical "blown-physics" underlying RBW aerodynamics, and the validation of CFD models against unpowered and powered wind tunnel data.
This study introduces a structured methodology for identifying Control-Equivalent Turbulence Input (CETI) models using rotorcraft flight dynamics simulations. A new Moving Spatial Turbulence Field (MSTF) model was developed to generate input datasets, enabling CETI model identification for four distinct aircraft configurations: a generic utility helicopter resembling the H-60, and three small-scale multi-rotor UAS types—a quadcopter, hexacopter, and octocopter. The CETI models were validated in hover using frequency-domain analysis, with flight-derived CETI models serving as the benchmark. To further assess model performance in forward flight, CETI models for the H-60 were identified at airspeeds ranging from 0 to 140 knots in 40- knot increments. Results indicated that the MSTF-based CETI models for the H-60 effectively captured key spectral features of the flight-test data, though some deviations were observed, potentially due to variability in atmospheric conditions. In contrast, the CETI models for the multi-rotor UAS configurations showed closer alignment with flight data, likely reflecting more accurately captured atmospheric inputs during simulation. These findings highlight the promise of simulation-based CETI modeling for both rotorcraft and UAS, offering valuable insights into turbulence effects across diverse platforms and flight regimes.
This study examines the ability of a large (1200 lb gross weight) hexacopter with collective pitch controlled rotors to tolerate single motor failure. The hexacopter is considered in various orientations, and the vehicle is trimmed with one motor inoperative (OMI). Unlike RPM-controlled hexacopters, which were trimmable but uncontrollable in hover, and were untrimmable in cruise with an aft-rotor failure; with pitch-control the hexacopter is controllable in hover as well as trimmable for failure of any rotor in cruise (including an aft rotor failure). The study examines how pitch controls, and thrust are redistributed amongst the operational rotors, post-failure, for the different hexacopter orientations. For each case, the maximum thrust and torque increases on any individual rotor, and the total power increase, post-failure is examined. It is found that the hardest to trim cases are those where the hub torque and the hub drag induced yaw moment of the failed rotor add, and fault compensation for these cases usually comes at a high cost in terms of torque penalty and power requirement (necessitating use of more powerful motors and batteries). The results from the study indicated that operating the pitch-controlled hexacopter in an edge-first configuration with a clockwise spinning rotor 1 is the best choice from a fault tolerance perspective.
This study presents the development and application of a refined momentum source term methodology for synthetic turbulence generation in urban flow simulations. By embedding divergence-free, three-dimensional turbulence fields consistent with the von Kármán energy spectrum directly within the computational domain, the approach enables flexible and efficient turbulence generation with minimal sensitivity to grid stretching. The method is validated through Large Eddy Simulations (LES) of flow around a representative urban vertiport model under varying turbulence intensities (10%, 20%, and 30%). Results demonstrate that the generated synthetic turbulence significantly alters the flow field, reducing recirculation zones, promoting earlier shear-layer reattachment, and stabilizing the flow above the vertiport platform—key factors for safe eVTOL operations. Instantaneous flow analyses reveal that secondary tip vortices (STVs) persist even in the presence of strong inflow turbulence but lose their periodicity, explaining discrepancies with prior spectral analyses. Overall, the momentum source term approach offers a practical and effective tool for modeling atmospheric turbulence and gust conditions in urban air mobility and rotorcraft simulations.
During helicopter air-to-air refueling the rotor of the helicopter might enter the slipstream of the tanker aircraft's propeller. Based on blade element momentum theory, the impact of the accelerated air within the propeller slipstream on rotor blade aerodynamics (thrust, rolling and pitching moments) can be solved analytically. Also, DLR's comprehensive rotorcraft code has been used with the Pitt-Peters induced inflow plus rotor-rotor interference model. Additionally, DLR's free-wake code was used for both the propeller and the helicopter main rotor, including mutual wake-wake-interactions. The helicopter rotor's collective and cyclic controls needed for disturbance rejection are computed with all these models for a typical air-to-air refueling scenario without and with blade flapping motion. A propeller wake affecting the retreating side of the rotor requires much larger control inputs to retrim than an impingement on the advancing side. The results of all modelling approaches are compared to each other and generally a reasonably good agreement is found, despite their very different levels of complexity and computational effort.
In this paper the time accurate coupling between the high fidelity CFD code FLOWer and the multi-body dynamics code SIMPACK is presented. To facilitate this coupling a socket-based data exchange was developed and used to exchange aerodynamic forces and kinematic data. Two flight states were investigated: a hover and a forward flight. To obtain a reasonable initial flight state a previously obtained, trimmed solution was taken as the base. This study shows the feasibility of the strong coupling approach with the direct influence of the helicopter motion on the flow field and vice-versa. As expected, the factor limiting the overall performance is the runtime of the CFD simulation. The effort of running the flight mechanics simulation and the data exchange necessary for the strong coupling is negligible compared to this runtime.
The paper presents a general framework for building an aeromechanic model in FLIGHTLAB, suitable for high fidelity, pilot-in-the-loop simulator. The focus is on aerodynamic modeling of AW609 tiltrotor in Airplane Mode flight regime. The framework can be extended to helicopter and conversion modes with additional considerations for rotors-airframe aerodynamic interference. It can also be adapted to different tiltrotor geometries, with some adjustments depending on their peculiarities. The model uses Blade Element Theory loads evaluation of lifting surfaces, corrected with tabulated distributed loads to tune FLIGHTLAB predictions against high-fidelity aerodynamic references. Bluff bodies are modeled using force and moment tabulated data. Verification was conducted against reference data in wind tunnel mode and against flight data in trim analysis. The proposed method allowed to match lift distribution on slender bodies, as well as lift and drag integral loads, with aerodynamic references. Trim analysis has shown satisfying accordance with experimental data for all the comparison parameters. However, rotor aerodynamic modeling is still being investigated to improve correlations in torque prediction. Additionally, installation effects, such as those related to the interaction between the wing and fuselage with the rotors, are under examination to address biases in flap motion evaluation.
In this study, we employ the Polynomial Chaos Expansion (PCE) and Monte Carlo (MC) methods to quantify the uncertainty of unsteady loading noise generated by a hovering rotor under the presence of vertical gust. The unsteady loading noise is predicted using a frequency-domain approach combined with a quasi-steady Blade Element Momentum Theory, accounting for time-varying aerodynamic forces. A sinusoidal gust is modeled using two parameters: gust length and gust amplitude. Then, the uncertainty quantification (UQ) of the unsteady loading noise is performed using the PCE and MC with these two gust parameters. The UQ analyses show that the largest uncertainty in unsteady loading noise occurs at the rotor axis, and PCE and MC simulations show good agreement. The individual and combined effects of the gust parameters on the acoustic uncertainty are analyzed, and parallel coordinate plots are utilized to visualize combinations of the gust parameters that produce noise outliers. It is found that the gust length leads to larger uncertainty in the unsteady loading noise than does the gust amplitude, especially at fifth harmonic. Furthermore, low magnitude of high harmonic noise is produced even at high gust amplitudes when combined with wide gust lengths.
An extensive test campaign was conducted at the National Full-Scale Aerodynamics Complex 40- by- 80-Foot wind tunnel to acquire performance, loads, and acoustics measurements of the Joby Aviation propeller across a variety of operating conditions. The dataset provided validation of the design methodology as well as verification of computational tools. The Vold-Kalman filter was used to extract the shaft-coherent propeller noise in hover to obtain the residual noise, representing the broadband noise. This data verified broadband noise tip speed scaling laws as well as a low-order empirical model for overall sound pressure level. The OVERFLOW/PSU-WOPWOP method was used to simulate the propeller in pure edgewise flight and shown to accurately predict propeller performance. The low-frequency acoustics were predicted well but the solver underpredicted frequencies above 300 Hz, possibly due to the inability to capture the turbulent component of the blade-wake and blade-vortex interaction. The computational method was used to simulate the propeller at various angles of attack in low-speed edgewise flight and captured trends and spectral content up to 1 kHz. The predictions showed noise sources moving from root to tip as the propeller angle of attack increased. However, the high-frequency content was not captured for all cases. The experimental campaign was successful in characterizing the acoustics of the Joby Aviation propeller, but more research is needed to be able to properly predict and understand the noise sources throughout the flight envelope.
The NASA Revolutionary Vertical Lift Technology project aims to support and guide the development of vertical flight vehicles for the benefit of the U.S. rotorcraft community and to increase the quality of life of the public. As part of this effort, the Multirotor Test Bed (MTB) – designed and built by NASA – has been tested twice at the U.S. Army 7- by 10-Foot Wind Tunnel at NASA Ames Research Center in 2019 (MTB1) and 2022 (MTB2). This study utilizes MTB2 experimental data for sensitivity studies on rotor aerodynamic performance of a quadrotor configuration using two mid-fidelity tools, the Comprehensive Hierarchical Aeromechanics Rotorcraft Model (CHARM) as well as Blade Element Theory based disk modeling in the OVERFLOW CFD solver. Additionally, this study leverages analyzing computational rotor performance predictions with experimental data to help identify future test configurations for the upcoming MTB3 test in the National Full-Scale Aerodynamics Complex 40- by 80-Foot Wind Tunnel.
The empennage of a helicopter is largely responsible for its stability in forward flight. Its performance is mainly determined by its aerodynamics. In this paper, the empennage of a CoAX 2D ultralight research helicopter is analyzed in detail. For this purpose, the helicopter was equipped with flow measurement devices and flight tests were performed, covering different flight conditions. Measurements from a nose boom as well as the pilot’s control inputs and helicopter's position are available for evaluation. For the empennage in particular, seven-hole flow probes were mounted on it and various cameras were used to record the movement of the surface tufts.
This paper introduces a comprehensive model, specifically developed to inherently capture interactional effects. Due to the high computational cost associated with the large analysis matrix including variations in angle of attack, angle of sideslip, velocity, and weight, a surrogate model is used in creating aerodynamic databases. This database, which reflects interactional effects under a wide range of flight speed, angle of attack, angle of sideslip, and weight configuration, is integrated into a rotorcraft analysis tool. Simulations are performed, and results are compared against flight test data for the T625 Gökbey, covering low-speed, high-speed, rightward and climb conditions. The results highlight the impact of interactional aerodynamics on flight characteristics and load predictions. Overall, the study emphasizes the importance of including interactional effects to ensure accurate and reliable rotorcraft design in the early design stages without requiring flight test data.
This paper deals with the uncertainty estimation of identified frequency and damping trends of whirl flutter modes, obtained by applying system identification methods on experimental data. In particular, two different identification approaches are considered, namely the free-decay analysis by using Matrix Pencil algorithm and the Data-Driven Stochastic Subspace Identification method (SSI), applied to system response to stochastic input. The two approaches lead to as many uncertainty estimation methodologies, both leveraging the bootstrapping statistical process. A full validation procedure is then set up to assess the accuracy of such methods in correctly quantifying the uncertainty of the estimated statistics. To do so, a wing-rotor state-space linear numerical model is used to simulate system response to both dwell and stochastic inputs. The state space numerical system aims to replicate the ATTILA wing-rotor wind-tunnel model, which falls in the framework of Clean Sky 2 European program to investigate the possible occurrence of whirl-flutter instability in tiltrotor configurations. Hence, one of the proposed methodologies is applied to ATTILA experimental data for both modal identification and uncertainty estimation, and the processed flutter trends are reported in a few conditions of particular interest due to the progressive approaching of whirl-flutter condition.
This paper carries out experimental investigation of propeller and wing interactions under various geometric variations such as the horizontal and vertical distance between the propeller axis and the leading edge of the wing under different angle of attack conditions for a half wing setup for a wing made of symmetric airfoil. Rotor and wing performance is measured using independent six-component load cells. Through this study it is identified that for a wing made of symmetric airfoil optimal aerodynamic performance is significantly influenced by the position of the propeller. Positioning the propeller near the leading edge (x/c = 0.25) and on the negative side of the y-axis (y/c = −0.75) yields the best lift-to-drag ratios and enhanced lift, particularly in the moderate α range (4°–6°). Forward movement of the propeller along the x-axis (towards x/c = 0.75 or 1.00) increases drag and adversely affects performance.
Preparation for Powered Flight (PPF) is a critical phase for Dragonfly, the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) mission to Saturn’s moon Titan. During PPF the descending Lander is lowered below the Backshell and uses its rotors to remove or “despin” any residual yaw motion of the vehicle. A 1/2-scale model of the Dragonfly PPF configuration was tested in the National Full-Scale Aerodynamics Complex (NFAC) 80 by 120-foot wind tunnel to measure aerodynamic loads and surface pressures on the Lander and Backshell. The results were used to improve understanding of the complex aerodynamic interactions and provide validation data for the Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) simulations used to develop the aerodynamic databases for full-scale, Titan conditions. Configurations tested in the wind tunnel included Lander-alone-no-rotors (L), Lander-alone-with-rotors (LR), and Lander-with-Rotors-and-Backshell (LRB). Both LR and LRB configurations were tested at multiple descent velocities and pitch and roll attitudes. The eight powered rotors were operated in nine combinations of active and inactive rotors, using steps of increasing RPM from idle to maximum. The results were used to identify conditions that generated the desired yaw moment for despin as well as those that generated reduced or opposite sign moment. In parallel, CFD simulations applied the STAR-CCM+ toolset to the experimental geometry. Time-averaged virtual disks represented the rotors by adding spatially varying axial and rotational momentum to the flow. There was generally good agreement between experiment and CFD, but conditions having strong interactions between the rotors, Lander, and Backshell were found to be improved by use of more sophisticated time accurate and discrete blade models. The lessons from the experiment are being applied to the CFD for the full-scale Lander under Titan conditions.
Blade–wake interaction (BWI) is a significant source of broadband noise and is often dominant in rotors with high blade counts. Accurately capturing the resulting unsteady blade loading is computationally expensive and, therefore, drives the cost of BWI noise calculation. To address this challenge, a low-fidelity BWI noise prediction tool was developed using aerodynamic data from the blade element momentum theory (BEMT) and the lattice Boltzmann method (LBM) for a series of rotor configurations with medium to high solidity. Starting from a six-bladed baseline rotor, 13 additional configurations were generated by varying blade twist, taper, root collective, solidity, and blade count. The relationship between vortex miss distance and blade loading unsteadiness was quantified to construct a semi-empirical BWI noise model. The model predicted BWI noise with a root mean square error of 3.9 dBA and a mean absolute percentage error of 1%. It was subsequently integrated into a BEMT framework to produce aerodynamic and acoustic data for training a tandem neural network (TNN) that was employed to optimize two rotor geometries. The optimized designs achieved up to a 7% reduction in BWI noise and a 7% improvement in performance. Additional geometric modifications—including blade tip anhedral, forward sweep, and a mixed configuration—were also assessed using LBM, each demonstrating notable noise reduction.
The performance and acoustics of a scaled propeller designed for an eVTOL vehicle were investigated in axial and edgewise flight. The measured performance compared well with BEMT predictions in axial flight conditions. The noise produced by the propeller is dominated by broadband noise sources, where there is evidence of contributions from blade wake interaction noise, turbulent boundary layer trailing edge noise, and laminar boundary layer vortex shedding noise. The directivity of the noise was found to be dependent on the advance ratio. Beamform maps also identified changes in the dominant noise source at different observer locations as a function of advance ratio.
The next generation of Mars rotorcraft may involve an increase in scale and number of rotors. A key focus area that has been identified is to increase the fidelity of rotor wake modeling, including its impact on flight dynamics. To that end, this paper pursues the use of a Viscous Vortex Particle Method (VVPM) for mid-fidelity rotor wake predictions in Mars atmospheric conditions. Simulated aerodynamic hover performance, as well as control efforts in trimmed forward flight, of the Ingenuity Mars Helicopter with a VVPM wake is shown to correlate well with available experimental data. Qualitative and quantitative coaxial wake effects for Ingenuity-type rotors in hover and forward flight as predicted with VVPM are studied. Utilizing VVPM to evaluate rotor-rotor interference effects in a large-scale Mars hexacopter across a wide range of flight conditions showcases the capability to comprehensively model the induced wake of complex multi-rotor configurations within feasible computational cost. An approach to emulate interference effects derived from the VVPM data that is compatible with finite-state dynamic inflow models is demonstrated, exemplifying how VVPM can be adopted to inform flight dynamics analysis and control system design of next-generation Mars rotorcraft.
This paper describes the design, development, and testing of a full-scale eVTOL propulsor optimized for quiet and efficient operation. To design the propulsor, a design tool was developed for predicting the aerodynamic and acoustic performance of eVTOL propellers and rotors. The design tool consists of an aerodynamic prediction code, AMP (Aerodynamic Modeling of Propulsor), and an acoustics prediction code, OpenCOPTER, coupled with an acoustics propogator, PSU-WOPWOP, which can receive inputs from either an acoustic solver or high-fidelity CFD. The tool was used to design a coaxial eVTOL propulsor, and both subscale and full-scale blades were manufactured. The aerodynamic and acoustic performance of the subscale propulsor was tested in hover and edgewise flight in an anechoic wind tunnel. A custom test stand was developed and used to measure the aerodynamic and acoustic performance of the 8-ft diameter full-scale propeller in hover. The experimental results were used to validate the design tool.
Aeroelastic stability prediction is critical to the successful design, development and flight testing of rotorcraft. As configurations reach higher speeds, new challenges in high Mach number unsteady aerodynamic modeling need to be addressed, especially for higher frequency aeroelastic modes with significant coupling. In this paper, Linear Unsteady aerodynamics and Leishman-Beddoes attached flow models are applied and compared to 2D CFD (airfoil) and 3D CFD/CSD (rotor) analysis for operating conditions of interest. The Leishman-Beddoes model demonstrates improved agreement with CFD data. In the 2D assessment, RCAS is used to model a representative airfoil undergoing prescribed pitch and heave oscillations. CFD results are presented to compare each model (Linear Unsteady and Leishman-Beddoes). In the 3D assessment, a full rotor CFD/CSD test case is evaluated for aeroelastic stability and compared to RCAS standalone analysis. The RCAS rotor structural model is coupled with the HELIOS CFD code and a swashplate cyclic pitch input is used to excite a lightly-damped rotor mode. The transient response based on RCASHELIOS is compared to the standalone RCAS internal aerodynamic result for both Linear Unsteady and Leishman- Beddoes unsteady aerodynamics. This study demonstrates that the Leishman-Beddoes model can produce similar stability results to the computationally expensive coupled CFD/CSD approach of RCAS-HELIOS, but at a lower computational cost, even for critical high-speed conditions.
This paper presents an overview of the results from the second wind-tunnel test of the TiltRotor Aeroelastic Stability Testbed (TRAST). The objective of this test was to obtain experimental data for understanding the effects of tiltrotor parameters on whirl flutter and analysis-validation data for the prediction of whirl flutter across a range of system configurations. Frequency and damping were measured at multiple rotor speeds for pitch-flap-coupling angles ranging from -0°to -30°. In addition, measurements were made for changes in blade stiffness, air density and wing-pylon connection stiffness. The paper also presents the results from supporting measurements that may aid analysis validation, such as wing-only damping, rotor frequencies and non-spinning modal frequencies.
This study investigates the interactional aerodynamics of multi-rotor systems with longitudinally canted rotors, focusing on force, moment, and wake behavior. Experiments using two 24-inch, two-bladed rotors in hover varied cant angle (0–20°) and hub spacing (1.1–1.5D). Increasing longtitudinal cant angle had the greatest effect on maximum longitudinal force, (| Fx |), yielding a reduction of up to -6.18% per 1°. Hub spacing had greater influence, especially on longitudinal force, | Fx |, and pitching moment, (| Mx |), which decreased by up to -16.00% and -31.07% per 0.1D increase, respectively. Time averaged flow results from Particle Image Velocimetry (PIV), showed that larger hub spacings and cant angles improved wake separation and flow symmetry. These results provide foundational data for minimizing parasitic loads and maximizing aerodynamic performance in advanced multi-rotor designs.
Dragonfly is a rotary-wing lander, and its mission is to explore Titan. It will make multiple flights over several years to explore different sites on Titan. There is limited information on the chemical processes that led to life on earth. Among the other places in the solar system, Titan is the most like the early earth and therefore exploring its organic surface chemistry will help to better understand our own prebiotic history. During Titan flight the rotor induced unsteady aerodynamic loads, as well as the interactional aerodynamic loads due to the rotor to rotor and rotor to lander interferences drive the structural vibrations. Therefore, robust and accurate predictions of Dragonfly structural loads and vibrations are essential for designing a vehicle that can successfully perform its mission. This paper presents the structural loads and vibration predictions of the Dragonfly lander using Rotorcraft Comprehensive Analysis System (RCAS) coupled with the Viscous Vortex Particle Method (VVPM) inflow model as well as the high fidelity coupled Computational Fluid Dynamics/Computational Structural Dynamics (CFD/CSD) simulations. Elastic fuselage modal model, generated by the NASTRAN FEA, is also used to represent the dynamics of the flight lander in the simulations. Hub loads and the lander vibrations simulations are provided at multiple flight conditions. The paper also demonstrates how the comprehensive analysis can be used to provide insight on the design changes that can result in significant reduction of the structural loads and vibrations.
This paper expands on a previous exploratory investigation into the safety implications of helicopter operations at hospital landing sites. The paper analyses the interaction between rotor downwash, the turbulent wake shed from nearby buildings and the effect of varying windspeed and aircraft position. A RANS CFD method has been used to compute the mean airflow in the vicinity of a hospital helipad with a helicopter, representative of a Bell 412, hovering at three different positions around the site. The main rotor of the aircraft was modelled using a Virtual Blade Model, enabling a coupled solution between the airflow around nearby structures and the helicopter. The study examines the resulting airflow patterns and velocity magnitudes around the site for two incoming windspeeds and three varying aircraft positions. Results presented are focussed on areas where the rotor downwash is present and likely to impact pedestrians. The findings show that windspeed can affect how the downwash from the rotor is distributed through the local environment and highlights that, in certain areas, calculated air velocities are found to be at levels considered hazardous to pedestrians.
Enhancing rotor efficiency has been a persistent challenge in the development of micro aerial vehicles (MAV) especially for surveillance and covert operations. This study introduces a new Hybrid Flapping Wing Rotor (Hybrid FWR) configuration inspired by insect's wing flapping mechanics to address the efficiency limitation of traditional rotor designs. Unlike traditional rotary systems that rely solely on rotational motion, the Hybrid FWR combines rotational and flapping motions to significantly enhance lift generation. A comprehensive mathematical model was developed to analyze and predict the optimal aerodynamic performance, demonstrating that the Hybrid FWR configuration achieves a substantial improvement, with a power efficiency increase of up to 2.148-fold compared to conventional micro rotorcraft. Experimental validation was conducted to confirm the theoretical predictions, identifying an optimal hybrid ratio of approximately 0.7, which effectively minimizes aerodynamic resistance during the upstroke phase while maximizing lift during the downstroke. This bio-inspired hybrid approach addresses critical limitations of existing MAV rotors, such as limited operational endurance and range. The findings of this research contribute significantly to the advancement of micro rotorcraft technology, presenting a promising direction for future MAV developments with enhanced flight performance and energy efficiency.
This study presents an integrated optimization framework for rotor blade design that combines aerodynamic shape optimization and internal structural design within a unified multidisciplinary process. A variable fidelity modeling (VFM) approach is employed to efficiently optimize the blade outer geometry for improved figure of merit (FM) in hover and lift-to-drag ratio (L/Dq) in forward flight. Based on the optimized aerodynamic shapes, internal structural optimization is subsequently performed using a surrogate model for predicting cross-sectional properties, ensuring dynamic feasibility while minimizing blade vibration and weight. Final aeroelastic performance is evaluated through high-fidelity CFD/CSD loose coupling simulations. Optimization results show that individual designs achieve up to 6.5% improvement in FM or up to 6.6% improvement in L/Dq compared to the baseline HART II rotor. Furthermore, cross-validation comparing blades independently optimized by Seoul National University (SNU) and DLR reveals similar aerodynamic trends and performance, demonstrating the robustness and general applicability of the proposed framework across different simulation setups.
The Dragonfly relocatable lander was selected as NASA's New Frontiers mission in 2019 to explore the organic-rich surface of Titan, Saturn's largest moon. The coaxial quadrotor vehicle will fly to multiple geologic sites covering a distance of over 50 miles near the Titan equator. At each site, Dragonfly will sample materials, determine the surface composition, and investigate how far prebiotic chemistry has progressed on Titan. Upon arrival, the lander will enter the Titan atmosphere protected inside an aeroshell, which will descend and decelerate with parachutes. At an altitude of approximately 1 km above the ground, the lander will separate from the backshell and perform a controlled transition to powered flight. Prior to separation from the backshell and after the heatshield has been ejected, the Preparation for Powered Flight (PPF) sequence will be initiated, which ensures the lander is in a safe and stable state for autonomous descent. A critical element of PPF is the de-spin maneuver, where diagonally opposing rotors rotate at maximum speed to reduce any residual angular momentum by creating a yaw moment in lander body axes. This paper presents high-fidelity computational fluid dynamics simulations of the Dragonfly rotorcraft lander during the PPF sequence. Aerodynamic performance predictions are compared with test data from the National Full-Scale Aerodynamics Complex to validate the simulations and build confidence in the PPF simulation results. Blade-resolved simulations capture the unsteady and complex flow behavior in Titan's dense, low-temperature atmospheric conditions during PPF. The results are analyzed, providing insight into aerodynamic performance and the aerodynamic moments critical for mission success.
Current paper summarizes a correlation study of two flow solvers (CREATETE-AV Helios and Simcenter STAR-CCM+), routinely used at Sikorsky, with multiple model-scale wind-tunnel tests. The Helios modeling approach was aiming for a high-fidelity accurate simulation, whereas the STAR-CCM+ modeling approach was aiming for a fast turn-around time with reasonable solution accuracy with a relatively coarse mesh and simplifications. The two solvers generally agreed well with the test data within reasonable accuracy and captured the airloads and flowfield trends. The calculations presented herein show the impact of the turbulence model on component loads, the aerodynamic interactions among components, and the effect of transition modeling on rotor performance. The Reynolds-Averaged Navier-Stokes CFD model generally delayed separation and resulted in lower drag. By modeling the airframe supporting structure in CFD simulations, an improvement on correlation for inflow on the propeller plane was shown. Additionally, improvements in the rotor system L/De correlation were realized by including a turbulence-transition model, which reduces the rotor drag.
This study explores the aerodynamics of aerial screws, drawing inspiration from Leonardo da Vinci's visionary 16th-century designs. Using high-fidelity Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) analysis, the research identifies a vortex-based thrust generation mechanism, centered on the formation of a "da Vinci vortex"—a coherent helical structure critical to performance. Systematic investigations into the effects of pitch and taper variations reveal nuanced strategies for optimizing thrust efficiency. Bilinear modifications to these parameters achieve up to a 13% improvement in figure of merit over linear designs. Detailed wake analyses further elucidate the importance of early vortex anchoring, swirl minimization, and coherent wake contraction for maximizing aerodynamic efficiency. This work not only deepens the understanding of aerial screw physics but also lays the groundwork for their application in next-generation Vertical Take-Off and Landing (VTOL) vehicles.
This paper investigates the influence of wing-propeller aerodynamic interactions on the aeroelastic damping of a wing-propeller system. The system is modeled in the Rotorcraft Comprehensive Analysis System using the viscous vortex particle method for the propeller aerodynamics and the uniform inflow model for the wing. The aeroelastic damping characteristics are identified from simulated time-history data using a recently developed method that captures amplitude effects due to system nonlinearity. The damping characteristics identified using conventional methods based on linear assumptions are also presented for comparison. The results show that, at lower airspeeds, the local damping decreases with increasing propeller hub displacements, both with and without aerodynamic interactions. This amplitude-dependent behavior cannot be captured by conventional damping identification methods that average amplitude effects. Amplitude-dependent trends are exacerbated by wing flexibility. However, they become slight as the system approaches flutter, resulting in linear behavior close to the stability boundary. For a flexible wing, wing-propeller aerodynamic interactions destabilize the system. The impact of aerodynamic interactions on local damping decreases with larger propeller hub displacements, which might be attributed to the skewness of the propeller wake and the extent of its wash over the wing.
This paper explores a significant step forward, regarding the further detailed understanding of the Fenestron®. Since its patent in 1968 – for the Gazelle helicopter –, the shrouded tail rotor has been resized, inclined, modulated, etc. and has thus been continuously enhanced on different rotorcraft. Half a century after its invention, Airbus is once again exploring in more detail the magic of the Fenestron®, with the objective of optimizing it even further, for future helicopter applications. To grasp and observe properly some specific phenomena, a model (scaled to one third) capable of both unprecedented functions and modularities, was developed. The present paper will describe in detail the novel model and the related challenges and solutions. This model is capable of high rotor speed and dynamic pitch inputs, delivering power levels high enough to reach stall effects, while allowing the measurement of propulsive efficiency and to differentiate rotor vs fairing thrust. Furthermore, the model had to provide aerodynamic-shape modularity, both in the shroud, on the covers and on the tail gearbox supports. The first test campaign performed on this model allowed us to define design drivers and aerodynamic preferences. And since one idea often leads to another, another challenge is being addressed on this scaled mock-up: Reduction of the tail rotor noise level.
The UH-60A slowed rotor test campaign carried out at the 40- by 80-Foot Wind Tunnel at the U.S. Air Force's National Full-Scale Aerodynamics Complex (NFAC) provided valuable information of a classical helicopter rotor blades operating at very high advance ratios. This paper aims to show the correlation of the RCAS and HOST comprehensive analysis (CA) tools with respect to several experimental campaign cases. Particularly the influence of the rotor aerodynamic performance as a function of the advance ratio and the collective angle is studied. The influence of the shank drag modeling is observed and its importance to obtain accurate results is highlighted. The RCAS and HOST simulations are capable of reproducing the rotor performance trends observed in the test campaign. Furthermore, the correlation of RCAS and HOST with respect to the measured rotor loads data is studied for the advance rations of 0.4, 0.5 and 0.7 at iso-thrust coefficient conditions. The aerodynamic loads and the structural loads are analyzed by means of the sectional loads analysis and polar maps. Finally some conclusions are provided highlighting the correlation of the RCAS and HOST results as well as the impact of the advance ratio on the behavior of the blades.
The advent of electric propulsion technology has led to a paradigm shift in aircraft design over the past few decades. This shift has expanded the possibilities for design and optimization processes more than at any previous time. To support these advancements, efficient flight dynamics simulation models that can be employed in iterative optimization and design processes are essential. Among the modules of a typical flight dynamics framework—namely, control, flight dynamics, and aerodynamics—the aerodynamics module, which includes the rotor performance model, generally demands the most computational effort, thereby limiting simulation efficiency. In this study, a novel machine learning (ML)-assisted flight dynamics framework is developed, incorporating a Neural Network Blade Element Theory (NN-BET) model as the rotor performance module. The results show a 7- to 8-fold reduction in computational time compared to fast, physics-based frameworks utilizing efficient Blade Element Momentum Theory (BEMT) models, without compromising predictive accuracy. Furthermore, the modular architecture of the framework allows for easy adaptation to a wide range of practical applications by replacing modules with functionally equivalent alternatives. The demonstrated accuracy and computational efficiency of the proposed flight dynamics framework make it a highly promising candidate for optimization and design applications.
The subject of this paper is the conceptual development of two new configurations for HEMS Operations as a new fleet concept for the European theater. Previous studies showed an increase of the required flight range for an emergency patient transport. But in conjunction with an average share of less than 30% of the flights actually with the patient. In the most rescue missions an emergency physician is transported to the scene, the patients further transport is conducted on-road by an ambulance. Considering an improved flight performance, the first DLR design study revealed a growth of the maximum take-off mass of the primary rescue helicopter of 32%. That makes the rescue helicopter inefficient for the transport of only the emergency physician. Consequently, if an ambulance is already at the scene, an emergency doctor shuttle is the sensible approach. The requirements for such a configuration are developed from a feasibility study lead by the ADAC Air Rescue (ADAC Luftrettung), considering the design of a progressive multirotor configuration. This paper presents the state of the design process for both rescue configurations. This includes the definition of the external configuration, cabin design, propulsion architecture, aerodynamics, flight performance, wind tunnel test, and structural considerations.
This study investigates the evolution of axial and radial velocities in the downwash-outwash region of a counter-rotating coaxial rotor hovering in-ground effect (IGE). The presence of the ground deflects the axial flow of the rotor wake radially outward, with mean radial velocities reaching approximately 2Vh along the ground. Based on the observed velocity profiles, the wake was classified into three distinct regions: the downwash region characterized by maximum wake contraction, the transition region where flow turns from axial to radial, and the outwash region exhibiting wall jet behavior. Results show that increasing inter-rotor spacing d/R and rotor height above ground (z/R)l extends the downwash and transition regions, delaying the onset of radial outwash. Aerodynamic loads on personnel were estimated, showing maximum mean forces and moments of 120N and 120Nm, remaining within safety thresholds for untrained personnel. However, the loads exceeded these limits for heavy-category helicopters with higher disk loading. Instantaneous velocities revealed unsteady behavior driven by tip vortex convection, with peak velocities reaching 2.8Vh and peak loads approximately 50% higher than mean values, as identified using the 98th percentile approach. Frequency analysis confirmed that fluctuations at the rotor frequency dominated the unsteadiness in the rotor wake. These findings provide critical insights for safe rotorcraft operation near ground surfaces and contribute to informed vertiport design and personnel safety guidelines.
A velocity potential-based finite state model (VPBFSM) has been developed to analyze an isolated rotor in ground effect. The model uses mass source distributions to represent the ground and enforces the non-penetration of flow boundary condition. In previous VPBFSM approaches to impose this boundary condition, the r = j terms were excluded to avoid singularities. This exclusion required adjustments to the source strengths and ground rotor size in order to impose the boundary condition properly, which reduced the model’s robustness. In the present study, the r = j terms are incorporated using a solution for the gradient of the velocity potential from the literature, which avoids singularities. This inclusion allows for effectively enforcing the boundary condition without requiring adjustments. The model is applied to an isolated rotor in full, inclined, and partial ground effect cases, including analysis of the R−50 rotor using geometric and aerodynamic data from the literature. Results for full ground effect show excellent correlation with the Hayden model. The normalized induced torque also exhibits good agreement with experimental data for full, inclined, and partial ground effect cases.
Items per page:
50
1 – 50 of 1879