Browse Topic: Crash statistics

Items (161)
This paper examines the trends in rotorcraft accident statistics, particularly regarding Loss of Control In-flight accidents (LOC-I), with the aim of stimulating interest in new research relevant to this area. Despite recent safety initiatives, LOC-I rotorcraft accidents have been identified as a significant and growing contribution to accident rates. The fixed-wing commercial airline community faced a similar situation starting in the late 1990s and, through a coordinated international effort, developed a new training program to help reduce accident rates. Lessons learned from the fixed-wing work are presented to highlight the need for improved rotorcraft modeling tools to reduce rotorcraft accidents through higher-quality, simulator-based training programs. The findings from previous and ongoing rotorcraft modeling and simulation research are presented, and areas for further research are identified. A proposal is made in the paper for a workshop to bring together the key rotorcraft stakeholders to develop future steps in tackling rotorcraft LOC-I accidents.
White, MarkLu, LinghaiAdvani, SunjooCameron, NeilPadfield, Gareth
Computational and Experimental Analysis of Head Injury Criteria (HIC) in Frontal Collision of Car with Pedestrian2019-26-00161/9/2019
Road accident between pedestrian and motor vehicle causes severe injuries and even death of pedestrian. The accident statistics show that the possibility of injury to pedestrian is higher in case of collision with car on busy roads. In car and pedestrian collisions, the pedestrian’s head hits with car bonnet and suffer from multiple injuries such as skull fractures and brain injury. The role of car bonnet structural strength plays an important role in pedestrian head injury level. To provide enough structural strength the high bonnet thickness is provided with under bonnet stiffeners, however thick bonnet and stiffeners reduces deformation of the bonnet during collision and increases injury level to pedestrian. Hence optimum bonnet thickness, least number and geometry of stiffeners and enough structural strength is important for bonnet to reduce injury level. The aim of this study is to analyse the effect of car bonnet thickness, number and arrangement of under bonnet stiffeners on head injury levels with the help of head injury criteria (HIC). Head Injury Criteria (HIC) is a measure of the likelihood of head injury arising from an impact during a car crash. It indicatesthe level of injury caused during a particular crash. A typical modern car bonnet is selected for investigation with variety of bonnet material thickness and different configurations of under bonnet stiffeners and head injury criteria (HIC) is computed with the help of computer modelling. Further, head linear velocity, acceleration and head injury risk are predicted for probability of skull fracture. The geometry of bonnet is optimized with the help of optimization technique and optimized bonnet geometry is validated experimentally by designing a bonnet test facility and head form imparter.
Thombare, Dr. Dhananjay G
Driver Response Time to Cyclist Path Intrusions2018-01-05314/3/2018
Motor vehicle crashes with cyclists are on the rise, with a six percent increase in fatal crashes from 2006 to 2015 in the USA. Although some research exists on the response time of drivers to some types of path intrusions, data on the perception-response of through drivers to cyclists who fail to stop at a stop sign, and ride into the path of the vehicle has not been researched. The purpose of this study was to quantify the Driver Response Time (DRT) to a cyclist that intrudes perpendicularly in front of a through vehicle at an intersection where the driver has the right-of-way. The DRT was measured from when the cyclist is positioned at the stop sign until the driver reacts, whether by touching the brake pedal, swerving (steering wheel angle change of at least 2 degrees), accelerating, or a combination of those responses. 26 (NFemale = 13; NMale = 13) university aged licensed volunteer drivers participated in the study conducted at the University of Guelph Driving Research in Virtual Environments (DRiVE) lab using an Oktal complete vehicle driving simulator. After a brief practice drive to acclimatize to the virtual environment, participants completed the approximately 10 minute experiment drive during which the cyclist hazard was presented. About one quarter of drivers crashed into the cyclist, with a mean time-to-impact of 3.26 seconds. There were no gender differences in terms of DRT or collision rates.
Toxopeus, RyanAttalla, ShadyKodsi, SamOliver, Michele
Method to Optimize Key Parameters and Effectiveness Evaluation of the AEB System Based on Rear-End Collision Accidents2017-01-01123/28/2017
Rear-end accident is one of the most important collision modes in China, which often leads to severe accident consequences due to the high collision velocity. Autonomous Emergency Braking (AEB) system could perform emergency brake automatically in dangerous situation and mitigate the consequence. This study focused on the analysis of the rear-end accidents in China in order to discuss about the parameters of Time–to-Collision (TTC) and the comprehensive evaluation of typical AEB. A sample of 84 accidents was in-depth investigated and reconstructed, providing a comprehensive set of data describing the pre-crash matrix. Each accident in this sample is modeled numerically by the simulation tool PC-Crash. In parallel, a model representing the function of an AEB system has been established. This AEB system applies partial braking when the TTC ≤ TTC1 and full braking when the TTC ≤ TTC2. Lastly, the AEB system’s model is coupled to the kinematic of the vehicle in simulation for virtual trajectories preceding the collision point to evaluate the potential effectiveness of different combinations of TTC according to the collision velocity reduction effectiveness and the excessive avoidance performance. After the simulations of 4284 run with 51 combination of the parameters based on 84 accidents, the results show that among the four desirable combinations, TTC1 = 1.0 s and TTC2 = 0.6 s is suitable for collision avoidance while TTC1 = 0.9 s and TTC2 = 0.5 s has satisfactory excessive collision avoidance.
Zhao, MingmingWang, HongyanChen, JunyiXu, XiaoHe, Yutong
Analysis of Non-Police Reported Accidents on Indian Highways2017-26-00051/10/2017
The official Indian accident statistics show that the number of road accidents and fatalities are one of the highest worldwide. These official statistics provide important facts about the current accident situation. It is suspected that for various reasons not all accidents are reported to the official statistic. This study estimates the degree of underreporting of traffic accidents with casualties in India. In order to get a national overview of the traffic accident situation it is necessary to improve the knowledge about underreported accidents. Therefore, the in-depth accident database of “Road Accident Sampling System India” (RASSI) was analyzed [1]. This project is organized by a consortium that has collected traffic accidents scientifically in four different regions since 2011 on the spot which have been reported either by police or by local hospitals and own patrol by RASSI engineers. Thus, the level of underreporting is researched by comparing data from hospital records and police records in order to estimate the number of accidents which are not documented in official statistics. Based on a number of around 1 635 accidents mainly in rural area it was found that 32% of all documented cases are not recorded by the national police. Based on these findings it is assumed that the national statistics cover only about two-third of all rural crashes in India. Various characteristics of accidents can influence the percentage of underreported cases. Accident scenarios - e.g. classified by Accident Type - have different shares of underreported cases. RASSI data shows that every 2nd single vehicle accident (including pedestrian cases) is not notified in the official statistics. In the study the accident data is analyzed in detail concerning: Accident scenarios Road user category Injury severity Road conditions Infrastructural details Result of this study is an overview of the accident situation in rural area and point out the frequency of underreported accidents depending of typical accident characteristics. This information can be used to identify main causes of this phenomen.
Joerg, MoennichKumaresh, GirikumarLich, ThomasGeorgi, Andreas
A Methodology for Collision Prediction and Alert Generation in Airport Environment2016-01-19769/20/2016
Aviation safety is one of the key focus areas of the aerospace industry as it involves safety of passengers, crew, assets etc. Due to advancements in technology, aviation safety has reached to safest levels compared to last few decades. In spite of declining trends in in-air accident rate, ground accidents are increasing due to ever increasing air traffic and human factors in the airport. Majority of the accidents occur during initial and final phases of the flight. Rapid increase in air traffic would pose challenge in ensuring safety and best utilization of Airports, Airspace and assets. In current scenario multiple systems like Runway Debris Monitoring System, Runway Incursion Detection System, Obstacle avoidance system and Traffic Collision Avoidance System are used for collision prediction and alerting in airport environment. However these approaches are standalone in nature and have limitations in coverage, performance and are dependent on onboard equipment. There is a need to have an integrated solution for collision prediction and alerting to enhance the capacity and operational efficiency of the airports and airspace at the same time ensuring the safety of aircrafts and personnel. This paper proposes a comprehensive, fool proof, integrated solution employing multiple sensor technologies to seamlessly predict collisions in all the zones of airport environment and generate alerts and guidance to prevent the same. Proposed system employs multiple sensor technologies like Optical and Infrared cameras, Laser Range finders, and Primary and Secondary surveillance radars for object monitoring, adopt latest technologies such as advanced image processing, sensor fusion for object detection and path tracking [1], collision prediction and synthetic visual environment for enhanced situational awareness and video based alert generation in real time. Simulation results of a synthesized data analysis that obtained through application of data fusion on multiple data sources and 3D path tracking algorithms are explained in the case study section.
Thupakula, KiranSivaramasastry, AdisheshaGampa, Srikanth
The New Approach of In-Depth-Accident-Investigation based on the Methodology for Traffic Accident Database on Scenarios TADS2016-01-14724/5/2016
Estimating the potential benefit of advanced safety systems by simulation has become increasingly important during the last years. All over the world OEMs and suppliers carry out benefit estimations by simulations via computer models. Such simulations should, of course, be based on real world scenario such as the pre-crash phase of real world accidents. Several methodologies for building up accident scenarios have been developed in the past. This paper shows a new method for generating pre-crash scenarios directly from the reconstruction of the accident by using the software PC-Crash1. The new method was developed by the Medical University Hannover (MHH) and the Fraunhofer Institute for Transportation Dresden (Fraunhofer IVI). It is based on transferring all information (participant-, vehicle-, environment- and motion-data) from the reconstruction file into a scenario-database. In order to analyse the pre-crash situation of real-world accidents and changing boundary conditions (e.g. introduction of certain active safety systems), a socalled Pre Crash Matrix (PCM) was developed. Using the PCM philosophy and including 5 seconds before the accident in the crash analysis combined with the driving behaviours of the vehicles out of PC-Crash, it is possible to analyse, whether or not a sensor system would have been able to recognise the dangerous situation in time to avoid or mitigate the accident. Since intermediate simulation steps with several assumptions are rendered unnecessary, this new method, called TADS (Traffic Accident Database on Scenarios) ensures that there is no tolerance/deviation between the reconstruction and the scenario-database. Every reconstructed pre-crash phase of an accident can be directly imported to the scenario database. This paper will give an overview how TADS work and how it might be used by an example of heavy goods vehicles.
Otte, DietmarUrban, MartinJohannsen, Heiko
Motorcycle Stability Control - The Next Generation of Motorcycle Safety and Riding Dynamics2015-32-083411/17/2015
Anti-lock Braking Systems (ABS) for motorcycles have already contributed significantly to the safety of powered two-wheelers (PTW) on public roads by improving bike stability and controllability in emergency braking situations. In order to address further riding situations, another step forward has been achieved with Motorcycle Stability Control (MSC) system. By combining ABS, electronically combined braking system (eCBS), traction control and inertial sensors even in situations like braking and accelerating in corners the riders' safety can be improved. The MSC system controls the distribution of braking and traction forces using an algorithm that takes into account all available vehicle information from wheels, power train and vehicle attitude. With its ability to control fundamental vehicle dynamics, the MSC system will be a basis for further development and integration of comprehensive safety systems. The contribution of ABS towards motorcycle safety has been confirmed by numerous international research studies, making it the safety technology with the highest possible benefit for motorcycles available today. Recent investigations by Bosch accident researchers show the contribution of the MSC system to further increase the safety benefit for motorcycle riders by extending the acceleration and braking control functions to cover more riding situations. The MSC systems could avoid more than every 3rd accident with casualties involving a motorcycle in Germany. This paper focuses on these new motorcycle technologies developed with centralized system architecture and their safety benefits in preventing and mitigating motorcycle accidents with injuries and fatalities.
Lich, ThomasBlock, Wilko GordonPrashanth, S NHeiler, Brad
Accident Characteristics and Influence Parameters of Severe Motorcycle Accidents in Germany2015-01-14664/14/2015
The overall number of severely injured participants and fatalities in road traffic accidents has decreased enormously during the last decades especially in Europe, but casualties in the group of riders of motorcycles have only decreased in a smaller percentage. In countries of Asia the numbers of motorcycle casualties are increasing regarding the popularity of motorcycle riding. The aim of this study is to analyze the current accident situation of motorcycles in Germany with severely injured and killed riders of motorcycles with cubic capacity > 125 cm3 in Germany, to identify the characteristics in injury mechanisms and accident constellations to find countermeasures to be suggested for worldwide accident avoidance and injury reduction. The study was carried out on the basis of accident data of 1,493 drivers of motorcycles involved in traffic accidents in Germany. These accidents were collected by a scientific research team of GIDAS (German In-Depth Accident Study) in the area of Hannover and Dresden within the years 2000 up to 2013. For finding accident characteristic, two groups of different kinds of casualties are compared, first the group of MAIS 3+ severe injured cyclists (n=218) and second the group of MAIS 1 and 2 slightly injured cyclists (n=1,275). The injury risk is described on the probability to be injured, on special injury patterns as well as to be severely injured. The Abbreviated Injury Scale AIS is used for the assessment of injury severity. Furthermore person individual parameters like age, body mass index BMI and crash data like collision constellation, kind of collision partner and speed are considered and assessed in a multivariate analysis. The study points out that motorcycle accidents lead to severe injured MAIS3+ riders, when accidents with objects (including falls) and accidents with cars occurred. MAIS 3+ injured cyclists were clearly higher in the age group above 60 years compared to the age group 41-60. The age group 26-40 and the youngest group below 26 years had the lowest numbers of MAIS 3+ persons. Only the driving speed of the motorcycle and the relative speed at the point of collision show a significant influence on the overall injury severity of the motorcyclists.
Otte, DietmarFacius, ThorstenWiese, Birgit
Cycling Characteristics of Bicycles at an Intersection2015-01-14654/14/2015
Although traffic accidents in Japan involving bicycles have been decreasing yearly, more than 120,000 per year still occur. Few data exist regarding the mechanisms underlying bicycle accidents occurring at intersections. Such dangerous situations form the backdrop of the warning and automatic braking systems being developed for motor vehicles. By clarifying cyclist behavioral characteristics at crucial times, it may be possible to introduce a similar warning system for cyclists as a countermeasure to reduce accidents. The objective of this study is to clarify the mechanism of accidents involving bicycles and to obtain useful data for the development of a warning system for cyclists. A video camera and software investigated and analyzed cyclists' speed and trajectory at an intersection where many accidents occur. Cyclists entering the intersection from one direction were recorded. The results showed that the intersection offered poor visibility to cyclists, many of whom maintained their previous speed without stopping. Given these data, an improved infrastructure and a warning system using vehicle to cycle communication is desirable. Therefore, with construction of a warning system in mind, in this study we speculated on a timely warning that will contribute to safe cycling without causing alarm to the cyclist. If the warning should take place 2 s before the cyclist crosses the intersection, it would be effective for about 80% of the cyclists in this study, so our data have potential to contribute to the development of a warning system.
Nikaido, ShoWada, ShotaMatsui, YasuhiroOikawa, ShokoHirose, Toshiya
Driver Perceived Threat and Behavior in Rear End Collision Avoidance Situations2015-01-14144/14/2015
The focus of this paper is the threat assessment of perceived threat by drivers in collision avoidance situations. The understanding of the decision making process with regards to the initiation of a driver intervention is a crucial step to gain insight into driver's steering and braking behavior in case of an imminent threat (rear-end collision). Hence a study with various test subjects and a test vehicle has been conducted. The study has helped to understand how drivers behave in potential rear-end collision situations arising from the traffic situation (e.g. start of a traffic jam). This information is of major importance for designing autonomous collision avoidance systems and an important step towards autonomous driving. Autonomous driving in vehicles require system interventions to be initiated as early and safely as possible in order to avoid the collision and to avoid unstable vehicle dynamics situations. In parallel, collision avoidance maneuvers need to be balanced between early intervention by the system and delaying the system intervention long enough in order to ensure that the driver will not or is no longer able to intervene. For this purpose the above mentioned study was designed to determine the braking and steering onsets when the subjects start a collision avoidance maneuver in a rear-end collision scenario either by steering or braking. The results show that the driver intervention onsets are much earlier than the physical limits for both steering as well as braking. It can be assumed that the driver would not consider any system intervention beyond these onsets as an override by the system. Within this paper the results presented include data collected within a study conducted to determine braking and steering onsets applied by drivers in order to avoid rear-end collisions. Based on this information the driver perceived threat in potential rear-end collision scenarios using the in-vehicle steering actuator is assessed. In the end the results will be used as baseline data for the development of an autonomous steering collision avoidance system.
Shah, JitendraBenmimoun, Mohamed
New Trial Analysis of Characteristics of Accidents and Traffic Violations by Elderly Drivers in Japan2014-01-91275/9/2014
The number of elderly drivers is increasing in Japan and ensuring the safety of elderly drivers is becoming an important issue. The authors previously conducted an analysis of the characteristics of accidents and traffic violations by elderly drivers based on the number of accidents in which they were rear-ended. This method was used in order to exclude the influence of driving frequency. As a result of that analysis, it was found that the likelihood of violations committed by elderly drivers was not particularly higher than in other age groups, while the likelihood of accidents caused by them was higher. The risk of causing an accident was judged to be about two times higher in elderly drivers than in the 35-44 year age group. However, the methodology presupposed that collisions in which a driver is rear-ended are accidents that occur randomly, and that they occur with the same probability in each age group. To verify the results of that study, we attempted a new analytical method that uses the number of stop sign violations, which are considered to occur with the same probability among age groups, as an indicator of driving frequency in place of accidents in which a driver is hit from behind (rear-end collisions). In the new analysis the risk of causing an accident was judged to be 1.24 times higher in elderly drivers than in the 35-44 year age group. In general, the risk of accidents caused by elderly drivers is estimated to be lower than in the previous study.
Morita, KazumotoSekine, Michiaki
An Assessment of the Effects of Passenger Vehicle Weight and Size on Accident and Fatality Risk Based on Data for 1991 through 2007 Model Year Vehicles2013-01-07574/8/2013
Quantifying the independent effects of vehicle weight and size on overall vehicle safety is necessary in order to assess the risks and benefits of vehicle weight reduction. This paper describes the results of one-stage and two-stage logistic regression analyses of the effects of passenger vehicle weight, wheelbase, track, and footprint on fatalities per accident, accidents per exposure (e.g., vehicle-miles-traveled), and fatalities per exposure using national and multi-state traffic accident and exposure databases. The analyses were accomplished in two phases. The first phase used 1995 though 2000 calendar year data for 1991 through 1999 model year vehicles. The second phase used 2002 through 2008 calendar year data for 2000 through 2007 model year vehicles. The overall fatalities per exposure results tend to confirm the one-stage results previously reported by NHTSA, however the new two-stage results provide additional insight into the independent effects of weight reduction and size reduction on vehicle crash involvement, crashworthiness and crash compatibility. The sensitivity of the results to various databases, variables, and assumptions was also investigated. The results from both phases indicated that the estimated overall effects of passenger vehicle weight reduction (while holding vehicle size constant) on fatalities are small in comparison to other variables and may not be statistically significant depending on various key assumptions (e.g., controlling for changes in wheelbase and track versus changes in footprint, and the type of induced-exposure data that are used), and this is due to small or opposing effects of these variables on crash involvement, crashworthiness and crash compatibility.
Van Auken, R. MichaelZellner, John W.
Benefit Estimation of a Lane Departure Warning System using ASSTREET2012-01-02894/16/2012
It is known that the collisions caused by lane departure events account for range of percentages among the countries studied. To help prevent such collisions, the Lane Departure Warning (LDW) system has started to be introduced in production vehicles, but there is little research on its benefits and limitations so far. In this paper we performed an in-depth analysis of the collisions and driver-related essential variables for the lane-departure collision scenarios and demonstrated the benefit estimation process. The benefit of the LDW system is estimated by comparing lane departure events when the vehicle has no LDW, and how they change with the addition of LDW. The event without LDW was modeled in 5 phases: (1) before departure, (2) starting of the departure, (3) departed the lane, (4) at the impact with an object, and, (5) after the impact. “An extensive analysis was conducted of traffic crash data compiled by the Institute for Traffic Accident Research and Data Analysis (ITARDA). The results of this analysis were used to create models of each phase of an LDW event. The Advanced Safety System & Traffic REaltime Evaluation Tool (ASSTREET), which is based on Monte-Carlo Simulation, was then used to simulate a variety of collision types. The results of these simulations were validated by comparing the distributions of fatality, serious injury, minor injury and no injury that they generated to crash statistics for Japan. Then, the effect of the LDW system was added to the lane departure events. The drivers' response delay to the LDW and the possible reactions were measured in a driving simulator test. The comparison between events with and without LDW clearly shows which cases could be prevented by the use of LDW and the ones that could not be avoided, thereby, providing us with important guidelines to improve the system performance.
Tanaka, ShinMochida, TsutomuAga, MasamiTajima, Jun
Performance of Collision Damage Mitigation Braking Systems and their Effects on Human Injury in the Event of Car-to-Pedestrian Accidents2011-22-001711/7/2011
The number of traffic deaths in Japan was 4,863 in 2010. Pedestrians account for the highest number (1,714, 35%), and vehicle occupants the second highest (1,602, 33%). Pedestrian protection is a key countermeasure to reduce casualties in traffic accidents. A striking vehicle's impact velocity could be considered a parameter influencing the severity of injury and possibility of death in pedestrian crashes. A collision damage mitigation braking system (CDMBS) using a sensor to detect pedestrians could be effective for reducing the vehicle/pedestrian impact velocity. Currently in Japan, cars equipped with the CDMBS also have vision sensors such as a stereo camera for pedestrian detection. However, the ability of vision sensors in production cars to properly detect pedestrians has not yet been established. The effect of reducing impact velocity on the pedestrian injury risk has also not been determined. The first objective of this study is to evaluate the performance of the CDMBS in detecting pedestrians when it is installed in production cars. The second objective of this study is to evaluate the effect of reducing impact velocity on mitigating pedestrian injury. Firstly, impact experiments were performed using a car with the CDMBS in which the car collided with a pedestrian surrogate. In these tests, the velocity was chosen for the various test runs to be 20, 40 and 60 km/h, respectively, which were based on the velocity distribution in real-world pedestrian crashes. The results indicated that the impact velocity reduction ranged approximately from 10 to 15 km/h at the standing location of a pedestrian surrogate at both daytime and nighttime lighting conditions. These results show that the system has the potential to reduce pedestrian casualties from car-to-pedestrian contacts. Secondly, finite-element analyses were performed simulating vehicle-to- pedestrian impacts with the THUMS pedestrian models. The vehicle models selected for the study included a medium sedan, a minicar, and an SUV. Since head and chest injuries are the most typical causes of pedestrian deaths in car-to-pedestrian accidents, the risk of head and chest injuries was calculated when the impact velocity was reduced from 50 km/h to 40 km/h, 30km/h, and 20 km/h. The results revealed that an impact velocity reduction of 10 km/h mitigated severe pedestrian injury at impact velocities greater than or equal to 40 km/h. Specifically, a significant effect was observed in collisions with the medium sedan and SUV. In Japan, the CDMBS has just started to be installed in medium sedans. The pedestrian injury mitigation will be greatly improved if the system can be applied to various types of vehicles including SUVs in the future.
Matsui, YasuhiroHan, YongMizuno, Koji
Modeling of Pedestrian Behavior in Crossing Urban Road for Risk Prediction Driving Assistance System2011-28-008510/6/2011
In Japan, the number of occupant fatalities has decreased at high ratio due to the development of passive and active safety technology in recent years. However, the pedestrian fatality is still the major proportion of fatalities according to the statistics of traffic accident. Therefore, it is important to study and develop active safety technologies which target to pedestrian. By analyzing the traffic accident statistics, narrow road in urban area is one of the dangerous parts for pedestrian. And the dangerous case that pedestrian often gets into an accident is while crossing road outside of crosswalk. This study focuses on accidents which are caused by pedestrians suddenly crossing narrow urban roads. In such cases, drivers need to drive carefully, preparing for sudden crossing or unexpected dangerous behavior of pedestrians. Therefore, it is important for drivers to predict the accident risk due to the crossing pedestrian behavior in such narrow roads. The final goal of this study is to find out the hazard anticipation mechanism in such scenes and to design a driving assistance system, such as, a warning or intervention system. To design such a driving assistance system it is necessary to describe a model of sudden crossing or unexpected dangerous behavior of pedestrian. To describe pedestrian behavior in urban area, near-miss incident database is analyzed which has been developed by JSAE. This database includes all kind of incidents collected by drive recorder, or black box, attached to Taxis in down town Tokyo. By using the database, we constructed a mathematical model for quantifying pedestrian behavior from camera image data, and verified the validity of the method by computer simulation.
Aoyagi, SoichiroHayashi, RyuzoNagai, Masao
Analysis of Fuel Cell Vehicles Equipped with Compressed Hydrogen Storage Systems from a Road Accident Safety Perspective2011-01-05454/12/2011
The potential impact of real world accident scenarios on fuel cell vehicles equipped with a compressed hydrogen storage system is analyzed from a component point of view. Even though hydrogen compressed gas tanks can sustain very high loads, in this study a simplification is made. It is investigated to what extent different real world accident scenarios with conventional vehicles have caused deformation of the vehicle in the area where a hydrogen tank would have been integrated in a fuel cell vehicle. The study is based on accident data from the GIDAS (German In-Depth Accident Study) database. Deformation matrices for each passenger car in the database are defined over a deformation grid largely independent of vehicle type and shape. The matrices are combined to statistically analyze the occurrence of deformations in selected regions of a vehicle. The concept of cumulative frequencies is extended to two dimensional deformation matrices defined over a set of accident cases and a new algorithm is applied to calculate the cumulative frequency matrix which is discussed for the GIDAS sample. In addition, accidents which resulted in an intrusion up to an area where the compressed gas tank would likely be located are further investigated with respect to the situation in which they happened.
Bakker, JoergSachs, ChristianOtte, DietmarJusten, RainerHannawald, LarsFriesen, Flavio
Incidence of Frontal Impact Accidents and Crash Testing of Cars Equipped with Collision Imminent Braking Systems2011-01-10994/12/2011
The number of vehicles equipped with automatic emergency braking systems is rising. Today most high-end auto makers offer pre-crash systems with a sensor-based collision warning feature. These systems warn the driver both audibly and visually when their sensors detect an imminent crash. Depending on system range, the occupants are moved into an optimized position, seat belts are pretensioned and the brakes are prepared for faster or, if necessary, maximum deceleration. A key feature of these systems is their ability to provide autonomous partial to full emergency braking in critical situations, thereby reducing collision speeds. Until now, crash tests have failed to mirror accident situations in which vehicles are braked prior to impact. Thus, it has not been possible to test the effectiveness of pre-crash occupant positioning or to reproducibly analyze the benefits of occupant preconditioning by pre-crash systems. This paper will give a statistical overview of the incidence of frontal impact accidents. It will also present a crash test on a BMW 5 series equipped with a prototype pre-crash system and automatic full emergency braking. The car is decelerated automatically from the Euro NCAP test speed of 64 kph to 40 kph whilst still being routed by the crash test centre's intelligent hauling system. This test was conducted complementary to the efforts of the vFSS Working Group (Advanced Forward-looking Safety Systems).
Egelhaaf, MarkusRücker, Peter
Evaluation of the Repeatability and Reproducibility on BioRIDIIg In Rear-Impact Sled Test2011-01-02764/12/2011
A large study of rear-end collisions was conducted for the neck injury indicators and test procedures. Neck injury in low-speed rear-end collisions is a big issue because there are a lot of patients despite low-speed rear-end collisions. Europe, Korea and Japan introduced the specific part in the New Car Assessment Program to reduce whiplash injury in low-speed rear-end collisions. From the legal point of view, to reduce the frequency and severity of injuries caused by rearward displacement of the head in rear-end collision, USA, EC, Korea, Japan and others internationally cooperated to make the global technical regulation (GTR) in UNECE/WP29. In 2008, after much meandering, GTR No. 7 head restraints were established. However the GTR No.7 is not a unique regulation because many countries had their own opinions and domestic regulations, and many questions related to injury criteria and biomechanical issues of dummy remain unresolved. The Biofidelic Rear Impact Dummy II (BioRIDII) is regarded as possessing the most similar characteristics to human volunteers and Post-mortem Human Subjects(PMHS) in terms of its response to low-speed rear impacts. Although a great amount of research was conducted for repeatability and reproducibility on the BioRIDII, the research results did not directly suggest the neck injury criteria and limit values for the regulation. The purpose of this research is to review the proper neck injury indicators for the BioRID-II through the low-rear sled test on the 3set BioRIDII ver-g. A series of sled tests were conducted to assess the adequacy of neck injury indicators for the repeatability and reproducibility of results obtained on the 3set BioRIDII. The sled tests were performed according to the test procedure proposed by the Korea New Car assessment Program (KNCAP). Neck injury indicators including NIC, Nkm, upper & lower Fx, upper & lower Fz, T1 X acc, Head X acc, were analysed for each dummy. The results show that some criteria, such as the neck shear force, exhibit coefficient variation (CV) up to 20.
Kim, Si-Wooshim, So-JungSuh, Myung-Won
Threshold Time-to-fire Determination for SRS to Control Occupant Injuries in Real World Accidents2011-26-00941/19/2011
Supplementary Restraints Systems (SRS) are provided in automobiles for occupant protection in severe accidents. Real world accidents are a varied mix of types and severities; thereby a need exists to engineer such systems for adequate performance robustness. Statistical data suggests high serious to fatal occupant injuries due to inadvertent SRS deployments, or sub-optimal Time-to-Fires (TTF) which lead to bag induced injuries. This paper explains the work done on a project to establish requirements of SRS deployments in different load cases of low, medium and high severity. LSDyna and MADYMO CAE applications have been used for this work and final validation through physical tests. The study considers different real world accident types and involves analysis of occupant-restraints system interactions. It includes variations in occupant types and seat belt configurations. Injury values, occupant displacements and its proximity to airbags were the main criteria to arrive at deployment threshold parameters. Vehicle dependent accident speed determination which could necessitate SRS activation was estimated through this approach. The deployment matrix was thereby a combination of load case, time-to-fire and vehicle speed. The input parameters for electronics sensing calibration were derived and trade-off was validated. The restraints “no fire” and “must fire” threshold definition was established with clarity on transition zone. The study shall ascertain a robust “no fire” in slow speed accidents that drive insurance premiums for customers.
Khare, PratyushKudale, Shailesh M.Prasad, A. P. Krishna
Evaluation of Anti-Whiplash Seat Robustness for Multi-Peak Crash Pulses in Low-Speed Rear-End Crashes2009-01-12024/20/2009
The mechanism of whiplash is not well understood and thus preventing a certain motion or force in an occupant might not mitigate this injury. However, a number of injury criteria have been proposed to evaluate the neck injury risk in a rear-end crash. In the safety design of the seat and the headrest assembly, robustness or invariability of whiplash protection must be secured not only under the assessment pulses applied in sled tests but also under such pulses that show random multiple peaks in real-world car-to-car rear-end crashes. The aim of this study is to investigate a method of evaluating the invariability of whiplash protection performance in low-speed rear-end crashes, not with multiple injury criteria but with a single newly proposed objective function. The function was determined based on the hypothesis that the ideal seat is rigid in terms of such invariability. A series of finite element simulations were performed based on the design of experiments to obtain car-to-car rear-end crash pulses (delta Vs = 16 km/h and 24 km/h). The signal-to-noise (SN) ratio of the objective function was then evaluated based on the dynamic characteristics of the Taguchi method, using both the BioRID II model and a human model under actual usage conditions (seat and headrest configurations, including reactive and proactive types of headrest) and environmental conditions (car-to-car crash pulses) at the customer level. The optimal configuration, which maximized the SN ratio, reduced all the injury criteria used in this study except Nkm for the BioRID II model. The proactive type of headrest, having a configuration similar to the optimal one, showed more invariability in reducing the injury indicator values than the reactive type did. The neck width can affect the invariability of flexion and head-forward motion. The validity of the objective function, or the robustness evaluation method, might be verified by adding the detailed geometry and material characteristics of the superficial soft tissue of the neck to the human model.
Murakami, DaisukeChinmoy, PalAsano, Hirofumi
A Study of a Method for Predicting the Risk of Crossing-Collisions at Intersection2008-01-05244/14/2008
The probability or risk of traffic accidents must be estimated quantitatively in order to implement effective traffic safety measures. In this study, various statistical data and probability theory were used to examine a method for predicting the risk of crossing-collisions, representing a typical type of accident at intersections in Japan. Crossing-collisions are caused by a variety of factors, including the road geometry and traffic environment at intersections and the awareness and intentions of the drivers of the striking and struck vehicles. Bayes' theorem was applied to find the accident probability of each factor separately. Specifically, the probability of various factors being present at the time of a crossing-collision was estimated on the basis of traffic accident data and observation survey data. Accident probabilities were then estimated and compared for different types of intersections, driving patterns of striking vehicles and types of struck vehicles (automobile, motorcycle or bicycle). The risk of a crossing-collision was found to be high at unsignalized intersections when the striking vehicle is cruising at a steady speed and the struck vehicle is a motorcycle or a bicycle. The results suggest that this combination of factors should be given priority when implementing traffic safety measures. Moreover, this paper also shows that estimated accident probabilities can be used to estimate the accident reduction effect of a driver-support system with warning and information presentation capabilities when the system induces changes in driver behavior.
Hiramatsu, MachikoHagino, MitsuakiInoue, Hideaki
Effects of Different Vehicle Parameters on Car to Car Frontal Crash Fatality Risk Estimated through a Parameterized Model2006-01-11344/3/2006
For the purposes of analyzing and understanding the general effects of a set of different vehicle attributes on overall crash outcome a fleet model is used. It represents the impact response, in a one-dimensional sense, of two vehicle frontal crashes, across the frontal crash velocity spectrum. The parameters studied are vehicle mass, stiffness, intrusion, pulse shape and seatbelt usage. The vehicle impact response parameters are obtained from the NCAP tests. The fatality risk characterization, as a function of the seatbelt use and vehicle velocity, is obtained from the NASS database. The fatality risk is further mapped into average acceleration to allow for evaluation of the different vehicle impact response parameters. The results indicate that the effects of all the parameters are interconnected and none of them is independent. For example, the effect of vehicle mass on fatality risk depends on seatbelt use, vehicle stiffness, available crush, intrusion and pulse shape. As a result of this interaction, the net safety outcome from changes to one of these parameters to reduce fatality risk will depend on the state of the others. For example, vehicle parameter changes, such as increasing stiffness to prevent intrusion, may be beneficial to the belted occupants and counter-indicated for the unbelted; conversely, changes to benefit the unbelted may be counter-indicated for the belted. In general, the effect of changes made to different vehicle attributes intended to improve overall fleet fatality risk will depend on the state of the fleet at the time of the introduction of the changes. Consequently, short-term transitional effects will exist until the changes are complete throughout the fleet, thus rendering a new equilibrium.
Nusholtz, Guy S.Xue, JianqingShi, YibingFamili, FaribaXu, LanRabbiolo, Guglielmo
Evaluation of Accident Parameters in a Numerical Fleet for Assessing Compatibility2005-01-07074/11/2005
On behalf of NHTSA, the European commission and the Dutch Ministry of Traffic and Transport, the Safety department of TNO Automotive is performing numerical fleet studies using multi-body vehicle models. Currently nine vehicle models are available, each of a different vehicle class, two vehicle models with a modified front-structure. The aim is to develop strategies for evaluation of front-end structures minimizing the total harm in car-to-car crashes on a fleet-wide basis in different accident scenarios. For these studies multi-body models were constructed from existing finite element models. Front-end structure and passenger cell were modeled in detail to provide realistic deformation modes. Furthermore dummies, airbags, belts and main interior parts like dashboard and steering wheel were included. To qualify the performance of the multi-body vehicle models for crashworthiness in an entire fleet, a study on offset frontal angled impacts was performed. Several parameter sweeps over relevant accident and design parameters were performed using the multi-body models. The accident parameters included vehicle type, vehicle speed and frontal overlap. The design parameters related to the front-end geometry of the two smaller vehicles and the front-end stiffness of all vehicles. A total set of over 4200 scenarios was simulated. Conclusions drawn from statistical analyses of the numerical results were used to automatically identify typical crash scenarios and to investigate compatibility improvements in two vehicles within the vehicle fleet.
Kellendonk, GijsVan Der Zweep, CorMooi, Herman
Designing Telematic Devices to Meet the Functional Requirements of an Increasing Elderly Population2005-26-0731/19/2005
An increase in the number of elderly drivers presents a new and substantial global challenge to the automotive industry in developing the next generation of automobile and telematic devices to support the driver. Age-related changes in information processing are widely reported in the literature with varying levels of relevance to safe driving. The most significant age-related deficits are associated with visual attention, dual task performance, filtering of irrelevant information, reaction time, motor performance and sequencing, and have their greatest impact on complex road traffic situations where several channels of information must be processed in parallel and at speed. Such deficits are reflected in the driving habits and the type of accidents in which some older drivers are involved. In complex driving conditions most drivers would benefit from some form of in-vehicle assistive device or improvement in automobile design. However, research suggests that for older drivers, the design of some devices and automotive features developed to ease driver workload may in fact increase it. Therefore, more research is needed to ensure that future automobiles and telematic devices are designed to meet the functional requirements of the increasing elderly population. This paper reports the outcome of an age-related study of simulated driving. The aim of the study was to evaluate scenario specific criteria and thresholds to inform elderly inclusive automobile design, and towards design specification of in-vehicle telematic devices. Young and older drivers were required to turn right through the traffic flow at an urban T-junction during simulated driving with varying levels of complexity. The results of the study highlight the interactive nature of age-related information processing deficits and compensatory driving behaviours, and the challenges associated with specifying elderly inclusive design for safe automobiles and telematic devices. Outcomes also address important issues with regards to road safety and the well-being of older drivers.
Middleton, HelenWestwood, DianeKok, DirkRobson, Jeremy
Analysis of Rollover Injuries for 125 Occupants at a Single Trauma Center With Special Focus on Head and Neck Injury2004-01-03213/8/2004
Analysis of the National Automotive Sampling System (NASS) data reveals that vehicle rollover accidents account for a relatively a small number of accidents, but the associated frequency of serious injury is high compared to frontal or side impact. These data demonstrate the apparently elevated probability of head and neck injury during rollover, with head injury occurring more frequently, injured 4.5 times more frequently than the neck when considering all injuries. Automotive industry researchers have performed numerous rollover tests with instrumented ATD's and have predicted an elevated probability of neck injury with little chance of head injury. This contradicts field data (NASS-CDS) which suggests a high frequency of head injury with little chance of neck injury. This difference may be explained in part, through the different volumes of data presented in the literature. For example, while government accident statistics represent a sample of all accidents (∼ 5000 cases per year) occurring within the United States, individual car crash experimental reproductions represent a small proportion of car crashes. As such, it would be helpful to analyze 100% of cases from a given region(s) to aid in our understanding of rollover injuries. The objective of the current study was to thoroughly analyze 125 cases collected from a trauma one hospital to elucidate the head and the neck injury profile for rollover victims. The resulting data demonstrate the prevalence of head injury supporting the government accident data thus suggesting reconsideration of either current rollover accident experimental protocols or the biofidelity of the dummy in rollover. It should be noted, however, that removing relatively minor head and neck injuries (AIS 1 and 2) from the analysis shows that there is very little difference in the frequency of head and neck injury.
Pate, Biren J.Atkinson, Patrick JSadowski, Jason B.Fernandez, David J.
The Effects of Occupant Age on Patterns of Rib Fractures to Belt-Restrained Drivers and Front Passengers in Frontal Crashes in Japan2003-22-001610/27/2003
The injuries sustained by elderly car occupants in traffic accidents are usually more severe than those of younger occupants. Accident statistics data show that injuries to elderly occupants frequently occur in the chest. Belted drivers and front seat passengers in cars involved in frontal collisions were investigated using detailed data on traffic accidents in Japan. From a total of 246 vehicle occupants, the total number of injuries among the 167 occupants listed as injured was 462. Most of the injuries to the chest were minor ones such as skin abrasions or contusions. However, 21 occupants sustained rib fractures and 7 persons even sustained internal organ injuries. Younger occupants appeared not to sustain rib fractures even in higher impact collisions. Conversely, elderly occupants frequently experienced rib fractures near the seat belt line even under lower impact severity. It was also typically observed that rib fractures in case of airbag deployment were more often found in the lower part of chest compared with those cases of seat belt restraint alone. Symptoms of these differences in injury are described in detail in consideration of the gender and age of occupants, airbag deployments, and accident severity. In addition, regression analysis was carried out to evaluate the influence of age on rib fractures. Results show that rib fractures in elderly occupants occur at a delta V 30 km/h lower than that of younger occupants.
Shimamura, MunemasaOhhashi, HideyukiYamazaki, Minora
DEVELOPMENT OF TEST PROCEDURES AND PERFORMANCE CRITERIA TO IMPROVE COMPATIBILITY IN CAR FRONTAL COLLISIONS2003-06-00135/19/2003
Compatibility is now recognised as the next major step forward for improved car occupant secondary safety. The work reported here forms part of a research project that was undertaken to understand the current compatibility problems in car to car collisions and develop crash evaluation procedures that are suitable for consumer and legislative testing. The research performed to date has focused on the structural performance of vehicles in order to provide a safe environment for the protection of the occupants. This should also provide sufficient space to allow intelligent restraint systems of the future to operate effectively. This paper outlines the present understanding of compatibility for frontal impact collisions and reports the current state of development of three possible test procedures to address the fundamental issues, namely: structural interaction, frontal stiffness matching and passenger compartment strength. The development of a new deformable barrier face and revised performance criteria for the full width test to assess structural interaction are described. Analysis of the load cell wall data collected in EuroNCAP tests, to address the frontal stiffness problem, is reported. Performance criteria are suggested and future work necessary to help set performance limits outlined. Initial work to investigate the repeatability of the passenger compartment strength test and possible performance criteria are described. This research is being carried out in co-operation with the European Enhanced Vehicle-safety Committee (EEVC) and the International Harmonisation of Research Activities (IHRA) Working Groups, and is funded by the UK Department for Transport (DfT).
Edwards, MervynDavies, HuwHobbs, Adrian
Rear-End Collision Velocity Reduction System2003-01-05033/3/2003
In Japan, rear-end collisions occur at higher frequency than many other kinds of traffic accident. The causes of rear-end collisions were therefore investigated. Accident statistics was used to conduct a statistical traffic accident analysis and a questionnaire survey was used to conduct a detailed traffic accident analysis. Simulation was then used to perform an accident analysis on the basis of those studies. The results suggested that many of these accidents were caused by momentary inattention during daily driving. Research was therefore carried out to determine what kind of collision avoidance assist system would be effective for use at such times. Tests were carried out to measure the obstacle avoidance characteristics of drivers using actual cars, and control timing parameters were established. In this process, the warning timing was set so that it would not lose its impact as a warning and also so that it would not interfere with the driver. The system was configured to make up for delays in recognition and judgment by means of brake control. The method of brake operation to be used was studied using both computation and testing with actual vehicle. The brake operation timing was set not to interfere with ordinary driver operations, and the deceleration was set to assist the driver’s avoidance maneuvers. The result was creation of a system capable of contributing to the reduction of rear-end collisions.
Kodaka, KenjiOtabe, MakotoUrai, YoshihiroKoike, Hiroyuki
Vehicle Frontal Collision: Comparative Analysis Between Brazilian and United Nations Regulations2002-01-356011/19/2002
1) Frontal crash regulation was introduced in Brazil in the early seventies. It was CONTRAN Resolution no. 463/73, item 4, which was based in the United Nations regulation (ECE R 12), that was state-of-the-art at that time. It reflected very well the concerns that existed then: during the test a vehicle was launched at a speed of 48 km/h against a rigid barrier. After the crash-test only two criteria were verified, in order to check conformity to the regulation: the steering-wheel center maximum displacement in the horizontal direction, which should be smaller than 127 mm, and the fuel quantity allowed to eventually leak from the circuit and reservoir, that should be lower than 28 grams per minute. In that methodology there was no evaluation of the possible injuries that could happen to the vehicle occupants. Test conditions, in terms of vehicle speed, type of barrier and relative position between vehicle and barrier proved later on not to be statistically very representative of the most common real life frontal vehicle collisions. This article shows some statistic data concerning the frequency and the type of accidents that cause more victims. New United Nations regulation concerning frontal vehicle impact, ECE R 94, which became effective in 1998, is presented and compared in details to current Brazilian regulation. It actually reproduces a frontal vehicle impact, at 56 km/h, against an asymmetric and non-rigid barrier, that only touches 40 % of the vehicle width, on the steering-wheel side. Two Hybrid-III dummies are placed in the front seats, in order to represent vehicle occupants. Those dummies are equipped with sensors, that can measure and register over 20 different parameters, including forces, accelerations and displacements, in several organs of the dummies' bodies. Each one of those measured parameters is then compared to the limits defined by the regulation, in order to evaluate the injuries that real human beings would have suffered if submitted to the same kind of frontal crash involving the tested vehicle. Those criteria are called bio-mechanical criteria. It seems very important to update Brazilian regulation by introducing bio-mechanical criteria and test conditions that are more representative of real life accidents. Adoption of United Nations' ECE R 94 regulation, that is one of the most modern and comprehensive ones in the world, could be a good choice. By doing so new vehicle models would incorporate state-of-the-art passive safety features that would bring extra protection to their occupants and would surely contribute, along with the renovation of the car population, to improve national statistics on traffic serious injuries and fatalities.
Custódio, Fabiano B.Monteiro, Luiz F.Saltini, 44, Marco A.
An Analysis of Recent Accidents Involving Upper Extremity Fractures Associated with Airbag Deployment2002-01-00223/4/2002
Prior experimental and field studies have demonstrated an increased risk of upper extremity fracture due the deployment of frontal airbags. The experimental studies provide valuable insight as to likely injury mechanisms; namely, increasing proximity increases the risk of forearm fracture. Still, field data is needed to validate these experimental findings. The available field data has largely been derived from direct case study analysis or a review of government accident statistics. In both cases, the datasets were comprised solely of pre-1995 era vehicles. Such data represents early generation airbag designs and there has been little additional study in this area. In addition, there has been an absence of fracture pattern analyses as a function of airbag deployment and non-deployment. Such an analysis would help elucidate the role of the deploying airbag on upper extremity fracture in the current fleet. In the current study we analyzed the NASS database and cases admitted to our trauma service. Our analysis shows that the forearm was fractured most frequently and that airbag deployment is associated with a 2 to 3 times increase in the proportion of forearm fractures versus no bag deployment. Further, it was found that females were statistically more at risk to suffer a forearm fracture even after pair matching for airbag deployment exposure and occupant sex. The current study shows that airbag deployment increases the risk of forearm fracture as a proportion of all upper extremity fractures and that females are at an increased risk of such injury.
Atkinson, PatrickMclean, MichelleTelehowski, PaulKhan, ImranMartin, SidneyHariharan, PremAtkinson, Theresa
Improved Side Impact Protection: Design Optimisation for Minimum Harm2002-01-01673/4/2002
This paper describes a side impact crash simulation technique and optimisation process developed to select vehicle structural design, padding and airbag characteristics that provide the best protection for occupants of different size, gender and fragility in crashes of different type, direction and severity. This work is part of a collaborative research project between Australian car manufacturer Holden, Monash University Accident Research Centre and other partners with funding from a government research grant, to developed a design technique providing optimum protection to the Australian community involved in side impact crashes. Multi-variable optimisation using a full vehicle side impact finite element model is not currently feasible as this approach would use an impractically high level of computer resources. Consequently, a unique and extremely efficient side impact crash simulation technique has been developed to support the design optimisation process. Created using MADYMO3D software, this simplified side impact model incorporates only those parts of the structure that influence components interacting with the occupant. Reduction in computational complexity was achieved by the partial de-coupling of the side impact event. A full vehicle finite element computer model, including test dummy was utilised to predict the structural response to side impact, and this response was used as input for the new, simplified optimisation model. The commercial optimisation package Isight was used to control the optimisation process. Validation was performed using data from vehicle side impact tests, side impact sled tests and full vehicle finite element computer model predictions. Societal Harm1 has been used for the objective function. For each simulation, dummy injury responses were translated into injury risk via the use of Injury Assessment Functions, and then from injury risk into societal cost. During each iteration cycle, societal costs from simulations with different crash configurations and occupant types were weighted according to the crash frequency observed during field study, thereby giving the measure of total Harm for that given trial design. After iterating through the range of design variables, the best set of interior trim, restraint and structural parameters was selected to provide maximum community protection.
Nelson, DavidSparke, Laurie
Study of improved safety for minibuses by better seat and occupant retention2001-06-02346/4/2001
There is considerable interest in improving the crash safety of buses, minibuses and coaches despite their comparatively good safety record. Publicity given to accidents involving these vehicles has led to demand for safety measures, notably the installation of seatbelts in coaches and minibuses. This demand has been met to some extent in the UK by the recent requirement for all children, on journeys relating to school or other child activities, to be transported in vehicles fitted with seatbelts. Further UK legislation will require all new buses and coaches, apart from those specifically designed for urban use and standing passengers, to be fully equipped with seatbelts. However, the requirements for seatbelt anchorage strengths in these larger vehicles are less demanding than for cars. An evaluation of samples of seats, seatbelt systems and minibuses, the potential for improving their performance and the appropriateness of current regulations was undertaken. This paper describes: a study of the available UK national accident statistics, an in-depth analysis of the UK minibus accidents held in the TRL database of police files of fatal accidents, the selection of a suitable crash pulse for testing minibus seatbelt systems which represents the real life accident situation, tests of standard minibuses in order to establish the performance of current seatbelt systems, the development and testing of improved minibus seatbelt systems and suggestions for improved test methods for minibus seatbelt systems.
Lawrence, Graham J. L.
Items per page:
1 – 50 of 161