Browse Topic: Flight tests
The Sikorsky S-92® helicopter fleet, representing more than 300 aircraft and 2.6 million flight hours, is relied upon to support a large range of important missions across the globe. In previous efforts, a high-fidelity CFD-CSD based full-aircraft simulation methodology, co-simulated with production FCS, was developed and applied to model both coaxial aircraft and single main/tail rotor configurations (Refs. 1-5). The CFD solver is based on the CREATE™-AV HELIOS toolset (Ref. 6) and the CSD solver is based on Rotorcraft Comprehensive Analysis System (RCAS) (Ref. 7). The current paper further correlated the CoSim methodology (Ref. 1) with the S-92® helicopter flight-test database at both hover, cruise and edge-of-envelope maneuver flight conditions. The consistent correlations for flight dynamics, static and fatigue component loads at conditions across the flight envelope demonstrate the reliable predictive capability of the high-fidelity CoSim methodology to be-used as a virtual digital flight test and to support advanced design at early stage.
This paper presents results of flight tests conducted on a coaxial ultralight helicopter. An automated flight test evaluation method is presented and exemplified through its application to steady horizontal flight. The results shown include pilot controls, helicopter attitude angles, power, thrust and torque distribution between the rotors, rotor harmonic thrust components, and teeter angles, along with their rotor harmonic components across varying flight speeds. This study focuses on the dependencies of these parameters on center of gravity position and sideslip angle.
In this study, a multifidelity aeroelastic framework is presented for predicting trim conditions in rotary-wing aircraft, with the main focus placed on the DUST implementation and its application to helicopters and quadrotors. The methodology combines aerodynamic and structural solvers of different fidelity, specifically DUST and the multibody dynamics solver MBDyn, through the preCICE coupling interface to enable direct comparison with rigid and coupled aeroelastic solutions. The trim problem is formulated from the six degree of freedom rigid body equilibrium equations in a helical turn reference frame, naturally covering both steady and maneuvering flight. Although the same formulation can be extended to fixed-wing configurations, the present paper is focused on rotorcraft applications. The framework is first applied to the SA330 Puma helicopter, chosen for the availability of validated flight test data. The methodology is then extended to a multirotor derived from a NASA quadrotor, demonstrating that the same trim strategy can be transferred to distributed-lift rotorcraft. Results highlight the potential of the proposed approach to provide physically consistent and computationally affordable predictions of helicopter and multirotor equilibrium states.
This organizational process survey provides insight into the technical aspects of approved airworthy aircraft modifications applied in government organization vertical lift flight test. The publication reviews processes applied by the National Research Council of Canada's Flight Research Laboratory (NRC-FRL) and its Airworthiness Control System to enable research flight testing. Dominated by the need for integrating experimental payloads, the NRC-FRL embeds a Design and Fabrication Service organization for modification of internal and external client projects and flight test aircraft. In context of experimental flight testing, this work reviews technical information on process, facilities, and methodology for airworthy integration of flight test payloads. Information is used to synthesize recommendations in experimental vertical lift flight testing that satisfy both formal (regulated compliance) and informal (compliance intent) airworthiness requirements.
The paper discusses the design and high-fidelity flight dynamics modeling of a 13-lb lift-plus-cruise unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) using Rotorcraft Comprehensive Analysis System (RCAS) in order to (1) better understand its physics of flight during a wide range of maneuvers, and (2) provide insight into the fidelity needed to achieve quantitative accuracy when compared to flight test data. Wind tunnel tests of the full aircraft were performed at a 65% scale to provide lookup tables for the flight dynamics model. Flight test data was collected while providing high control inputs to excite a variety of dynamic states in hovering and cruising modes to systematically validate the physics model. Near quantitative agreement was observed between the model predictions and test data during hover; however, the predictions began to disagree at higher forward cruising speeds. To address the discrepancy between the prediction and experiment, the flight dynamics model was improved by learning a correction from flight test data using a neural network. This hybrid physics plus data-driven approach reduced the error between the physics model and experiment by 74% and only needing 12 minutes of flight data for training. This hybrid methodology presents an alternate approach to high fidelity modeling which only needs a relatively small amount of flight test data.
This paper presents the design, development, and subscale flight testing of an optionally-autonomous lift-plus-cruise (LPC) eVTOL aircraft for emergency response missions that bridges the gap between existing aerial capabilities and the needs of first responders. A 4+1 LPC configuration consisting of four vertical lift propellers and a single pusher propeller was selected to balance hover performance and cruise efficiency. The vehicle is sized around a 600 lbs gross takeoff weight with a 125 lbs payload capacity. VTOL and Pusher propeller blades were optimized using parametric studies, resulting in a high Figure of Merit and propulsive efficiency. Trim analysis demonstrates efficient hover to cruise transition, lift-to-drag ratios of 10-11 between 70-90 knots, and propulsive efficiency exceeding 0.9 at the cruise speed of 100 knots. The subscale configuration utilized a simulation framework for trim and optimization of flight control laws, which were subsequently implemented on a 1/3-scale subscale demonstrator. Subscale flight tests showed stable hover and robust trajectory tracking under wind disturbances throughout the flight envelope, which demonstrates the feasibility of the proposed LPC architecture.
Recent flight tests and simulations have suggested that the outwash from eVTOL air-taxis could be larger than conventional helicopters of equal weight and thus pose greater safety issues for their operation than previously anticipated. This has prompted interest in the analytical and experimental study of the aerodynamics related to multi-rotor aircraft outwash. This paper will describe work investigating some of the related issues, specifically (1) how wake models and wake model parameters impact outwash predictions in comprehensive rotorcraft analyses and (2) considerations when scaling results from model scale to full scale. This work will also compare outwash predictions for conventional and multi-rotor VTOL aircraft obtained with a Lagrangian free-vortex wake model and with an Eulerian velocity-vorticity grid based wake model.
The Rotor Blown Wing (RBW) is a tailsitter Vertical Takeoff and Landing (VTOL) Unmanned Aerial System (UAS) configuration that leverages cutting-edge autonomous flight controls through Sikorsky's MATRIX™ technology to create a highly capable, efficient, and scalable technology platform. By combining the benefits of fixed- and rotary-wing aircraft, the RBW configuration eliminates the need for traditional UAS launch and recovery infrastructure. This paper describes the RBW-5 prototype, a 100-pound, dual 5-foot diameter proprotor demonstrator, and discusses the comprehensive evaluation of its design and operability through a combination of flight tests, wind tunnel experiments, and computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations. The results demonstrate the maturity of the UAS and highlights key accomplishments of the RBW-5 program, including successful autonomous takeoff and landing and transitions between hover and forward flight, the extraction of critical "blown-physics" underlying RBW aerodynamics, and the validation of CFD models against unpowered and powered wind tunnel data.
This paper discusses the development of a quantitatively-accurate non-linear hybrid flight dynamics model of a hover-capable Air-Launched Tailsitter Unmanned Aerial System (ALUAS) in order to 1) understand its dynamics during complicated maneuvers, and 2) provide a high-fidelity framework to develop novel control laws. Wind tunnel tests were conducted on a 1:1 scale model of the full aircraft to measure the airloads, which were used in the simulation as a lookup table. Flight tests of the ALUAS were performed in hover, transition, and cruise to collect a large amount of unique state measurements by providing large excitations to induce highly transient motion. The flight dynamics predictions using Rotorcraft Comprehensive Analysis System (RCAS) software were then compared with experimental flight test data. To correct any discrepancies in the RCAS physics-based predictions, a correction was learned from the experimental measurements, making use of the large amount of collected flight test data. Using a neural network to learn this correction, the end result was a quantitatively accurate neural network assisted flight dynamics model. The accuracy of current simulations in complex flight states successfully demonstrates the applicability of the proposed methodology for correcting the dynamics model of novel out-of-the-box aircraft configurations.
Urban Air Mobility (UAM) aircraft are highly susceptible to turbulent wind disturbances when operating near buildings in complex urban environments. Microscale wind phenomena, combined with the unconventional designs of UAM aircraft, increase the risk of performance deviation, the overall duration, and the cost of flight tests for certification. A way to overcome this would be through simulation-based flight tests. Therefore, this study simulates a UAM aircraft landing vertically behind an isolated tall building, considering four different wind scenarios: no wind, uniform wind fields at low and high spatial resolutions (assumed constant across the airframe), and non-uniform fields with spatially varying velocity profiles at individual rotor hubs. The resultant flight test data are then used to quantify the impact of microscale wind characteristics on landing performance by systematically analyzing the rotor performance, aerodynamics, control response, and trajectory deviation.
In April of 2024, Sikorsky flight tested an open loop Higher Harmonic Control system on an S-97® helicopter. The S-97® helicopter is a prototype aircraft, based on Sikorsky's X2 Technology™, that first flew in May 2015. It has contra-rotating, stiff in-plane main rotors with fly-by-wire controls, and a pusher propeller. This paper describes the HHC design, how it was implemented on the aircraft, how it was tested, and what the test results were.
The empennage of a helicopter is largely responsible for its stability in forward flight. Its performance is mainly determined by its aerodynamics. In this paper, the empennage of a CoAX 2D ultralight research helicopter is analyzed in detail. For this purpose, the helicopter was equipped with flow measurement devices and flight tests were performed, covering different flight conditions. Measurements from a nose boom as well as the pilot’s control inputs and helicopter's position are available for evaluation. For the empennage in particular, seven-hole flow probes were mounted on it and various cameras were used to record the movement of the surface tufts.
Several efforts have been made to develop Flight Test Maneuvers for Handling Qualities evaluations, aimed at quantifying the effects of vehicle characteristics and assistance systems on a Helicopter Air-to-Air Refueling mission profile. However, these Flight Test Maneuvers have not achieved widespread adoption, likely due to the substantial logistical challenges associated with tanker deployment. Depending on a tanker aircraft not only incurs significant costs but also requires extensive organizational effort and prior testing, before Handling Qualities can be evaluated for the aerial refueling capabilities of a new rotorcraft design. Additionally, these available Flight Test Maneuver setups are not standardized or widely applied to the same degree as Mission Task Elements of the Aeronautical Design Standard, which limits repeatability and comparability. A new approach is proposed to address these limitations by introducing a repeatable, standardized method to reveal Handling Qualities deficiencies considering a worst-case situation of Helicopter Air-to-Air Refueling. This approach involves analyzing drogue motion to create a synthetic, deterministic target forcing function, based on the summation of several sine waves. Resulting laws of motion are applied to a target tracking task replicating a drogue chasing scenario by projecting all required references into the pilots' field of view. Piloted simulator studies conducted at the Air Vehicle Simulator (AVES) of the German Aerospace Center (DLR) demonstrate a high degree of similarity in pilot control behavior between the proposed Flight Test Maneuver and actual simulated Helicopter Air-to-Air Refueling.
The Sikorsky BLACK HAWK® is the primary medium lift helicopter for the U.S. Army performing a wide range of missions that encompass Air Assault, MEDEVAC, CSAR, Command and Control, and VIP transport. The Multimission UH-60M is one of the latest in the BLACK HAWK helicopter product family, more capable, more survivable, more maintainable, more powerful, and more effective than its predecessors. In previous efforts, a high-fidelity CFDCSD based full-aircraft trim and maneuvering simulation methodology was developed and applied to model both coaxial aircraft and single main/tail rotor configurations (Refs. 1-4). The CFD solver is based on the CREATE™-AV HELIOS toolset (Ref. 5) and the CSD solver is based on Rotorcraft Comprehensive Analysis System (RCAS) (Ref. 6). The current paper further enhances the previously developed 6-DOF CFD-CSD full-aircraft trim methodology to robustly handle the trim solution for the single main/tail rotor configurations. The enhanced methodology was applied to rotor control loads and aircraft performance calculations at both steady level flight and aggressive Angle-of-Bank (AOB) turn maneuver conditions, including comparisons with available flight test data. The simulation results demonstrate a consistent correlation with flight test, including at stall conditions. The high-fidelity full-aircraft CFDCSD simulation approach provides an efficient, accurate and robust methodology for aircraft performance, control loads and stall boundary predictions to support advanced design at early stage.
By its seventh flight after the first take-off, the RACER (Rapid And Cost-Effective Rotorcraft) demonstrator smoothly reached the targeted 220kts speed in stabilized forward flight, validating the high-speed compound architecture developed by Airbus Helicopters in the frame of Clean Sky 2 programme. During the flight envelope exploration, the dynamic behavior of the main rotor was carefully assessed, by monitoring the vibratory loads and validating its aeroelastic stability. Particular care was taken to validate the predicted stability domain of the Dual Rotor phenomenon, a particular case of flap-lag coupling associated with high-speed flight conditions. This paper presents the most significant results shaping the success of RACER flight test campaign. After having introduced the theoretical background and the associated analytical equations, the simulation framework based on the comprehensive analysis tool STORM is presented to discuss the numerical resolution of the stability problem. Then, the rotor dynamics loads and airframe vibratory behavior of RACER are closely examined to demonstrate the absence of any sign of instability, in the various flight conditions offered by its rotor and wing configuration. At last the flight test results are compared to the computed stability domain to assess the margins and estimate the high-speed potential of the rotorcraft.
This paper introduces a comprehensive model, specifically developed to inherently capture interactional effects. Due to the high computational cost associated with the large analysis matrix including variations in angle of attack, angle of sideslip, velocity, and weight, a surrogate model is used in creating aerodynamic databases. This database, which reflects interactional effects under a wide range of flight speed, angle of attack, angle of sideslip, and weight configuration, is integrated into a rotorcraft analysis tool. Simulations are performed, and results are compared against flight test data for the T625 Gökbey, covering low-speed, high-speed, rightward and climb conditions. The results highlight the impact of interactional aerodynamics on flight characteristics and load predictions. Overall, the study emphasizes the importance of including interactional effects to ensure accurate and reliable rotorcraft design in the early design stages without requiring flight test data.
The Sikorsky Boeing SB>1 DEFIANT is a technology demonstrator aircraft that was built under the Joint Multi-Role Technology Demonstrator (JMR TD) program to address the next generation performance requirements of the US Army Future Vertical Lift (FVL) initiative. The Main Rotor Gearbox (MRGB) incorporated several low Technology Readiness Level (TRL) technologies to improve power density and meet challenging program requirements for gearbox empty weight fraction. After the conclusion of the flight test program the ground test Main Rotor Gearbox was disassembled and evaluated to raise the TRL level of these technologies. The technology insertions, teardown observations, and laboratory test results are discussed.
A robust velocity stability augmentation system was developed for the CoAX 600/2D coaxial-rotor helicopter to enable safe testing of a fly-by-wire system on an optionally piloted variant of the aircraft, developed by Piasecki Aircraft Corporation. The control law design and subsequent stability analysis were based on a validated nonlinear model of the CoAX 600 rotorcraft. A subset of helicopter handling qualities were evaluated through both analytical methods and piloted simulations, conducted with and without the stability augmentation system. Additionally, flight test data contributed to the analysis, albeit to a limited extent.
Acoustic flight testing of rotorcraft often involves generating noise source hemispheres to gain an understanding about the aircraft's acoustic emissions. However, aerodynamically complex Urban Air Mobility and Future Vertical Lift vehicles may not maintain a steady aerodynamic state during flight, making source hemispheres measured using traditional linear arrays unreliable or difficult to interpret. To address this challenge, all emission angles need to be measured simultaneously. This has lead to the concept of the two dimensional 'snapshot' array layout. A mathematically defined microphone distribution was utilized to achieve uniform coverage on the source hemisphere. Within the chosen distribution, two lower microphone count distributions are embedded, allowing for a comparison of the effects of number of microphones. The array was deployed as part of a joint Army/NASA acoustic research flight test in July of 2024. Data were collected using an MD530F helicopter as the test vehicle, executing both steady and unsteady flight. Analysis of the array resolution is used to determine adequate channel count and spatially varying sensitivity to array density.
This paper presents a robust and adaptable control system for tilt-wing aircraft, developed by Dufour Aerospace. The transitional tilt-wing aircraft, Aero2, combines the vertical takeoff/landing capabilities of helicopters with the high-speed range of fixed-wing aircraft. Addressing the inherent control complexities required to maintain control and stability, the developed system employs established control techniques, utilizing linearization at trim points and gain scheduling based on wing tilt. The architecture comprises a Control Allocation module for optimal actuator management, a Control Augmentation System utilizing an LQRI controller enhanced with a feedforward component for precise attitude tracking, and a Unified Velocity Controller for seamless transitions between ground speed tracking in hover and airspeed tracking in cruise. Special challenges unique to transitioning aircraft to ensure control in all axes, including in windy conditions are addressed with operational strategies and control system modifications, validated through flight testing of a subscale and Aero2 aircraft. The resulting control system demonstrates effective velocity and attitude tracking across the flight envelope, enabling reliable piloted flight and automated missions.
While known and largely studied, the Vortex-Ring-State (VRS) phenomenon remains the cause of numerous accidents every year and many questions are still open. In order to better understand the VRS phenomenon on different kinds of helicopters and to evaluate the effectiveness of recovery manoeuvres such as the one proposed by Capt. Vuichard, the European Union Aviation Safety Agency (EASA) launched the Helicopter Vortex-Ring-State Experimental Research project (EASA.2022.C11). Both objectives required to set-up flight test campaigns on two helicopter types, with a total of eight flights performed during the project. In addition to the description of the procedures that such flights required, the paper presents the Flight Test Instrumentation used and the analyses of the flight test data, including vibration measurements. Thus, flight conditions at which the VRS starts to develop, main parameters that influence and contribute to VRS symptoms and effects, or the effectiveness of the recovery techniques currently applied are presented and discussed in this paper.
This paper presents handling qualities (HQs) research findings for electrical Vertical Take-off and Landing vehicles. Testing in the Vertical Motion Simulator (VMS) investigated handling qualities of vehicle configurations having a degraded powertrain. Powertrain components, including batteries and electric motors, can degrade as the vehicle is flown. This paper investigates the impact of low battery charge and high motor temperature degradations on the pilot's ability to execute precise maneuvers. Pilot comments and ratings that were collected from four rotorcraft test pilots in VMS testing are used to quantify the effects that powertrain degradations had on the HQs of the vehicle.
Aeroelastic stability prediction is critical to the successful design, development and flight testing of rotorcraft. As configurations reach higher speeds, new challenges in high Mach number unsteady aerodynamic modeling need to be addressed, especially for higher frequency aeroelastic modes with significant coupling. In this paper, Linear Unsteady aerodynamics and Leishman-Beddoes attached flow models are applied and compared to 2D CFD (airfoil) and 3D CFD/CSD (rotor) analysis for operating conditions of interest. The Leishman-Beddoes model demonstrates improved agreement with CFD data. In the 2D assessment, RCAS is used to model a representative airfoil undergoing prescribed pitch and heave oscillations. CFD results are presented to compare each model (Linear Unsteady and Leishman-Beddoes). In the 3D assessment, a full rotor CFD/CSD test case is evaluated for aeroelastic stability and compared to RCAS standalone analysis. The RCAS rotor structural model is coupled with the HELIOS CFD code and a swashplate cyclic pitch input is used to excite a lightly-damped rotor mode. The transient response based on RCASHELIOS is compared to the standalone RCAS internal aerodynamic result for both Linear Unsteady and Leishman- Beddoes unsteady aerodynamics. This study demonstrates that the Leishman-Beddoes model can produce similar stability results to the computationally expensive coupled CFD/CSD approach of RCAS-HELIOS, but at a lower computational cost, even for critical high-speed conditions.
Developed in the frame of the European Clean Sky 2 program, the RACER High Speed Helicopter Demonstrator of Airbus performed its maiden flight on April 25th, 2024. In the continuity of the previous high-speed demonstrator X3 (1st flight in 2010) the RACER is a 7/8t (15000 / 18000 lb) class compound helicopter powered by two SHE Aneto-1X engines, including a wing and two propellers. The tail rotor is removed as the two propellers control the yaw axis by differential thrust. At flight 07, with its initial default settings, it reached a true airspeed of 227 kts in level flight, exceeding its objective of 220 kts.
A cooperative flight test campaign between the US Army and NASA was performed. This test sought to characterize the acoustic emissions of a fully instrumented MD530F helicopter using a snapshot array and a phased array of microphones. The snapshot array of microphones aimed to provide even coverage across the surface of a hemisphere, providing an acoustic emission hemisphere in a single 'snapshot' of time. The phased array of microphones was designed to provide enough resolution to determine noise sources from each individual blade as well as perform source separation from main rotor and tail rotor emissions. Test conditions for the characterization effort were chosen using a traditional one-factor-at-a-time approach as well as three design of experiment approaches. Characterization conditions included constant speed level flight, descent, and ascent conditions. Transient maneuver conditions were also captured over the snapshot array. The vehicle instrumentation included measurements of pilot controls, optical sensors to measure blade azimuth locations, pitch link loads, along with strain gauges to measure structural loads, blades and fuselage. This report will provide an overview of the test, document the data acquired, and provide some initial results.
A cooperative acoustics flight test campaign between the US Army and NASA was performed in which design of experiments (DOE) approaches were used to plan the flight test conditions. Three DOE designs were used, a face centered central composite design, circumscribed central composite design, and a hexagonal design. A traditional one-factor-at-a-time approach was also used, and interpolation points were planned to test for the strength of the DOE approaches. This paper documents the design methodology, discusses how response surface models were fit to the data, evaluates the overall response of the models, and evaluates the individual DOE designs. The response surface models were also used to design new test conditions of interest during the experiment, and that process is also documented. For the first time, DOE was shown to be an exceptionally useful tool for rotorcraft acoustics flight test planning, while the full power of the approach has yet to be reached.
The influence of ground, wall, and corner boundaries on multirotor vehicle performance was investigated through a series of controlled flight tests. Changes in rotor inflow profiles were represented by near-field rotor pressure measurements captured by a custom Kiel probe wake rake. Ground effect was characterized by reduced thrust and power requirements, primarily driven by the vehicle fuselage, which induced regions of reduced pressure and increased flow unsteadiness around the airframe. Operating near a wall boundary was found to restrict airflow into the portion of the rotor disk closest to the wall, leading to increased power requirements to maintain hover and a consequent reduction in performance. While vehicle orientation had minimal impact on overall rotor performance, it did influence local rotor inflow behavior near the wall, depending on the relative position of the interaction region formed with adjacent rotors. As the vehicle descends from the isolated wall effect into corner effect, created by the intersection of the wall and ground, an exchange between the dominating ground and wall effects is observed, with corresponding ground heights and wall distances identified.
We present the flight testing and integration of the Microsoft HoloLens 2 as a head-worn display (HWD) in DLR's research helicopter. Building on its successful use in a helicopter simulator, initial flight tests confirmed its feasibility in a real helicopter. Current tests focused on system optimization, with head tracking identified as the critical component for hologram stability. Since the HoloLens' inside-out tracking fails in moving vehicles, it was fused with an external infrared tracker, automatically calibrated via an optimization approach adaptable to various trackers and mounting positions. A test pilot with HWD experience rated the system as fully functional, enabling the first successful experiments with holographic Mission Task Elements. Beyond the helicopter, the HoloLens was tested in a car and on a high-speed boat, where holograms remained spatially stable despite high-frequency movements, with a maximum low-frequency error of 0.6° in heading. Static errors depended solely on the external tracker's quality. These results demonstrate the HoloLens 2's potential for operational use in dynamic vehicle environments, enhancing immersion. Its mixed-reality features and adaptability proved particularly valuable for rapid research and development across platforms.
Big Data technologies have become quite ubiquitous in the last years, allowing for the storage of substantial amounts of data, typically flight test data as recorded by the flight test installation. On recent helicopter prototypes, we generate in excess of 50 GB of raw data per flight hour, usually in a format not adequate for efficient large-scale processing. With some specific optimizations and the setup of a specialized infrastructure, there are now practicable means to store timeseries in ways that allow for requests spanning hundreds or thousands of flights to complete within minutes, opening the way to some substantial savings and new insights. However, to make the most of these data and make informed decisions it is often quite important to store contextual data that go beyond the pure timeseries data, typically on helicopters where optional installations can have a significant impact on aircraft performance or behavior. This paper explores the various kinds of data and metadata related with flight tests, how to collect them and relate them with one another in order to maximize raw data value and avoid some common pitfalls. We define more accurately the data of interest, where to collect them and some ideas to further improve data collection in the future.
This paper explores the effect of addition of a horizontal tail on the longitudinal stability and performance of a Biplane Tailsitter Unmanned Aerial Vehicle (UAV). Biplane tailsitters a type of hybrid UAVs, often exhibits poor longitudinal stability during forward flight, necessitating continuous active control through application of differential motor thrust to maintain attitude. To address this challenge, this work proposes the integration of a horizontal tail on a quadrotor biplane tailsitter UAV, aiming to improve pitch stability and control authority during critical flight phases. Experimental flight data was utilized to determine the appropriate sizing of the elevator. A detailed flight dynamics model validated the effectiveness of the elevator control. The design was validated through outdoor flight testing, comparing the performance of tail-less and tail-attached configurations. The results demonstrate that the modified design results in a reduction control power requirement for pitch control on the motors, enhancing longitudinal stability, and improved ascent and descent rates. This study provides a systematic approach to improving the operational capabilities of tailsitter UAVs, contributing valuable insights for the design of future UAVs requiring enhanced maneuverability and efficiency in VTOL and forward flight modes.
Low-level flight, defined by high-speed operations near terrain, represents a significant challenge in military rotorcraft missions while providing strategic advantages, such as radar evasion and heightened surprise. Recent conflicts highlight the urgent need for advanced low-level flight capabilities in the design of new rotorcraft. The close proximity to ground obstacles, combined with the complexities of piloting, necessitates precise control and robust handling qualities to prevent accidents. However, existing handling quality standards, such as MIL-DTL-32742, reveal limitations in assessing low-level maneuvers. Given the diverse array of new rotorcraft designs, driven by initiatives like the U.S. Army's Future Vertical Lift and NATO's Next Generation Rotorcraft Capabilities, a customized handling qualities evaluation for each design is impractical. In response, a performance-driven strategy has been implemented, scaling Mission Task Elements to align with aircraft performance capabilities. This approach identifies handling quality gaps across the Operational Flight Envelope, concentrating on the aircraft’s effectiveness in achieving task success under varied conditions. Prior simulator studies validate the effectiveness of this method for assessing different configurations. This paper presents flight test results using DLR's ACT/FHS research helicopter, confirming a set of scalable Mission Task Elements developed at DLR's AVES and NASA's VMS simulators. Pilots utilized a Head-Mounted Display for task cueing, eliminating the need for physical infrastructure. The Mission Task Elements proved suitable for evaluating the low-level handling qualities of the ACT/FHS. Although the provided Head-Mounted Display facilitated Handling Qualities evaluations, it encountered some hardware limitations. The scaling for different airspeeds met pilot expectations, and wind compensation functioned as anticipated, enhancing the independence of flight tests from environmental conditions. These findings lead to recommended updates for task descriptions and course cueing requirements, confirming desired performance tolerances.
Flight test students must explore a wide range of helicopter dynamic responses to learn how to assess conditions ranging from good conditions operation to those approaching, or even experiencing, loss of control. To introduce this evaluation process, the Flight Test and Research Institute (IPEV) implemented a helicopter flight dynamics model. This model is stitched in the x-body velocity (u) and y-body velocity (v) to achieve more accurate simulation, combined with a Variable Stability Augmentation System to assess different conditions prior to experiencing them in real flight. The use of robust control, where a fixed controller is applied to flight control systems under various operating conditions, presents an alternative to the traditional gain scheduling technique commonly used in aeronautical systems. This paper explores the potential to reduce controller design complexity while evaluating the impact on the helicopter’s full flight envelope through quantitative analysis and handling qualities evaluation by piloted simulation according to ADS-33E-PRF standard.
Dufour Aerospace designs and manufactures an automated tilt-wing aircraft for critical cargo delivery missions. Emphasizing operational efficiency, the platform integrates path generation and tracking techniques tailored for the unique dynamics of tilt-wing flight and builds upon the existing lower level control. While there exist a myriad of methods for high-level aircraft automation ranging from PID to MPC, they often require a trade-off between complexity and the capability to handle non-linear dynamics of the system they are controlling. Hence, a lightweight, deterministic geometric path generation approach using clothoid-based transitions between three waypoints and a robust SO(3)- based path tracking controller adapted for tilt-wing dynamics are presented. Additionally, a high-level automation framework is introduced that includes failure mode handling for GNSS loss and communication breakdowns. This system ensures mission continuity and operational safety while supporting flexible mission planning. The methods are validated through extensive flight testing on both small and large-scale aircraft. The latter prove the scalability, safety, and reliability of the presented solution for tilt-wing aircraft automation and enhance the aircraft's capabilities in real-world emergency response and complex operational scenarios.
This paper investigates the use of multi-modal cueing through full-body haptic feedback to enhance pilot-vehicle system (PVS) performance, reduce mental workload (MWL), and increase situational awareness (SA) in both good and degraded visual environments (GVE/DVE). Piloted simulations were conducted using an H-60-like flight dynamics model in a virtual reality (VR) motion-based simulator, evaluating two ADS-33-like mission task elements (MTEs) – precision hover and slalom – under visual-only and combined visual and haptic feedback conditions in both GVE and DVE. The H-60 flight dynamics were augmented with a dynamic inversion (DI)- based stability augmentation system (SAS), implementing rate-command/attitude hold (RCAH) response type on the roll, pitch, and yaw axes and altitude hold response type on the vertical axis. The SAS was designed to achieve Level 1 handling qualities per ADS-33 standards. The full-body haptic cueing strategy leveraged an outer-loop DI control law, which provided vibrotactile feedback to cue desired roll, pitch, and yaw attitudes to the pilot. Roll cues were delivered via tactors mounted on the upper arms, pitch cues via tactors on the chest and back, and yaw cues via tactors on the calves. Eight test subjects participated in the piloted simulations, including three U.S. Navy test pilots and five subjects with different flying experiences. Results indicated that haptic feedback significantly improved hover performance, reducing MWL and enhancing SA, particularly in DVE. However, in the slalom task, predefined haptic guidance misaligned with pilots’ individual control strategies, leading to performance degradation. This finding highlights the need for pilot-specific adaptive haptic feedback to mitigate inconsistencies in dynamic maneuvering tasks.
The transition phase of eVTOL aircraft poses a challenge in balancing energy efficiency and stability. This study presents the development and evaluation of an automatic flight control system for eVTOL transition phases, focusing on minimizing energy consumption while ensuring robust performance. The control architecture implements a hybrid response type combining Translational Rate Command below 5 knots and Acceleration Command Speed Hold above 5 knots, with control allocation dynamically adjusted based on airspeed and rotor shaft angle. Stability analysis reveals surge mode instability at high shaft angles due to negative speed stability derivatives, stabilized through carefully tuned feedback control. The system demonstrates Level 1 handling qualities against bandwidth, quickness, and disturbance rejection criteria when evaluated against MIL-DTL-32742 and MIL-STD-1797B standards. Simulation results verify the control system's ability to maintain precise acceleration/deceleration rates and attitude control while ensuring passenger comfort through limited pitch excursions. The control strategy achieves minimum energy transitions by locking rotor shaft angles to optimal schedules while avoiding excessive hub moments. Flight test maneuvers developed specifically for conversion phases confirm the system's capability to execute efficient transitions within defined performance boundaries. This research establishes a framework for certifiable eVTOL flight control systems that balance energy efficiency with robust performance across diverse flight regimes.
Time-resolved background-oriented schlieren (BOS) data are used to calculate the two-dimensional velocity field in the wake of free-flying full-scale helicopters in ground effect. The calculation is performed based on the density gradient pattern of the helicopter engine exhaust gas passing the BOS field of view. A classical BOS evaluation allows the visualization of density gradients such as vortices and the exhaust plume. The result is the BOS displacement field. Applying the two-dimensional divergence to this data results in a pattern that is constant in shape across multiple BOS images, but convects downstream with the outwash velocity of the helicopter. Using this data as input to a second, timeresolved evaluation, quantitative two-dimensional velocity fields are calculated. Choosing an appropriate strategy for preparing and evaluating the data is critical to reliable velocity estimation. Another important aspect is to distinguish between reliable velocity data and erroneous results in areas of reduced signal intensity due to a lack of thermal structures. The velocity data obtained are compared with an analytical outwash model and constant temperature anemometry data acquired simultaneously with the BOS images. The data show good quantitative agreement in areas of sufficient thermal structures within the field of view.
T-625 Gökbey is a light utility helicopter developed by Turkish Aerospace Industries since 2013. For T-625, automatic flight control system performance evaluation and development test campaign was conducted. In this paper, test campaign is investigated thoroughly. To assess and quantify the automatic flight control system performance and handling qualities, various different metrics and specifications were selected. This metrics covered both time and frequency domains. After metric selection, a set of test points were created. Most of the test points required delicate piloting and were easy to fail. Furthermore, a large flight envelope in terms of altitude and air pseed was needed to be covered. Hence, both test point number and required flight time estimates were very large. Hence, to not further increase flight time and need of test point repetitions, various different precautions were taken, such as using computer generated sweeps. While conducting tests, altitude kept constant while speed envelope tested. Then, altitude were changed to a new value and speed envelope is tested again. After each sortie, flight data were analyzed whereas control parameter updates were performed after finishing tests for all airspeed values for an altitude. After control parameter updates, validation tests were done to ensure that updated parameters provided expected performance. At this point, most of the test campaign is done and selected specifications were met for almost all the tested flight envelope.
As per certification requirements, for a large rotorcraft that does not meet the Category A requirements, the Height-Velocity (HV) avoid region must be determined in total power failure condition. The development of a digital twin representative of the real rotorcraft behaviour allows to reduce flight testing hours and to increase flight tests safety, especially in such critical conditions, thus decreasing risks and costs. In this work, an extensive simulation activity has been carried out to generate HV charts for a medium twin-engine helicopter in case of loss of both engines. An in-house software that emulates pilot logics has been exploited, coupled with a Flightlab model representative of the rotorcraft and validated against flight data. Manoeuvres performed after a dual engine failure were simulated starting from an all engine operative hover out of ground effect (HOGE) and in ground effect (HIGE) or level flight condition until landing, in a grid of heights and velocities and for different weights and altitudes combinations. Sensitivity analyses on the parameters that affect the manoeuvres the most have been performed and the effects of the assumptions and requirements at touchdown on the HV avoid region investigated.
U.S. Army Combat Capability Development Command Aviation and Missile Center (DEVCOM AvMC) and Georgia Tech Research Institute (GTRI) developed the Mission Systems Flying Testbed (MSFTB) to enable rapid evaluation of innovative technologies and integration approaches against Modular Open System Approach (MOSA) objectives. The MSFTB is a flight test capability to evaluate and demonstrate integration of mission systems to inform Army stakeholders on satisfaction of Modular Open System goals for the Army Aviation enterprise, Future Vertical Lift family of systems, and enduring aviation platforms.
ABSTRACT Updates to the military rotorcraft handling qualities specification are currently being considered that address the high-speed flight regime envisioned for the Future Vertical Lift platform of the US Army. A team that features industry and academia have developed and evaluated a set of Mission Task Elements (MTEs) that have been defined to address VTOL high-speed handling qualities. Following the mission-oriented approach upon which ADS-33E-PRF is based, the MTEs were designed to meet different levels of precision and aggressiveness. The attitude capture and hold MTEs that are the subject of this paper were defined to be precision, non-aggressive tasks that build upon fixed wing analogs. The MTE objectives, descriptions, and performance criteria were assessed and refined via several checkout piloted simulation sessions. Formal evaluations were then conducted by Army test pilots at four simulator facilities, each featuring a unique high-speed platform including a generic winged compound helicopter, two tiltrotor configurations, and a compound helicopter with coaxial rotors. To aid in the MTE evaluation process, baseline VTOL configurations were varied to achieve different handling qualities levels. Quantitative measures based on task performance and qualitative measures based on pilot ratings, comments and debrief questionnaires were used to assess MTE effectiveness. The piloted simulation results demonstrated that the attitude capture and hold MTEs provided an effective means to discern precision, non-aggressive handling qualities in high speed flight.
ABSTRACT Updates to the military rotorcraft handling qualities specification are currently being considered that address the high-speed flight regime envisioned for the Future Vertical Lift (FVL) platform of the US Army. The US Army's National Rotorcraft Technology Center (NRTC) project "Rotorcraft Handling Qualities Requirements for Future Configurations and Missions" is a U.S. Government and Industry co-funded three year research project. A Sikorsky-led project team that features industry and academia have developed and evaluated a set of Mission Task Elements (MTEs) that are defined to address rotorcraft high-speed handling qualities. Following the mission-oriented approach upon which ADS-33E-PRF is based, the MTEs were designed to meet different levels of precision and aggressiveness. Break Turn MTE was defined for non precision, aggressive applications in order to provide a suitable coverage of aggressive air combat maneuvers in future ADS-33. The MTE objectives, descriptions, and performance criteria were systemically developed via a series of piloted simulation sessions at each team's simulation facility. Formal evaluations were then conducted by US Army test pilots at four simulator facilities, each featuring a unique high-speed platform including an X2 Technology™ compound helicopter, two tiltrotor configurations, and a generic winged compound helicopter. To enhance the MTE evaluation process, baseline control law (CLAW) configurations were varied to achieve different handling qualities levels. Quantitative measures based on task performance and qualitative measures based on pilot ratings, comments and debrief questionnaires were used to assess MTE effectiveness. The piloted simulation results demonstrated that the Break Turn MTE provided an effective means to discern non-precision, aggressive handling qualities in high speed flight.
ABSTRACT This paper describes the modeling and simulation developments made in support of the AVX Joint-Multi-Role (JMR) Coaxial Compound Helicopter (CCH) handling qualities evaluation. The real-time full flight simulation model for the AVX-JMR CCH was developed in FLIGHTLAB and incorporates AVX's fly-by-wire (FBW) control laws. Extensive piloted simulation tests were conducted that cover various mission task elements (MTEs), including those described in the ADS-33E-PRF (Ref. [1]). The MTE test courses were set-up with proper visual cues in accordance with ADS-33E specification. For each MTE test, the test pilots evaluated the performance with ADS-33E handling qualities ratings (HQR) for achievable levels of aggressiveness and control precision. At the same time, the piloted simulation test data were recorded for post-test analysis to demonstrate the evaluation accuracy through comparison with ADS-33E performance standards. In addition to the piloted simulator tests, quantitative analyses were also conducted to assess the AVX-JMR CCH against ADS-33E hover/low speed and forward flight requirements using the ADS-33E handling qualities analysis toolkit in FLIGHTLAB. The quantitative analyses evaluated small and moderate amplitude attitude changes and inter-axis coupling characteristics of the AVX-JMR CCH against the Level 1, 2, and 3 criteria of ADS-33E-PRF. Both the qualitative and quantitative results are presented in this paper to summarize the handling qualities evaluation of the full flight AVX-JMR CCH simulation model.
This paper presents the preliminary results of the recent whirl flutter wind tunnel test campaign performed within the Advanced Testbed for TILtrotor Aeroelastics (ATTILA) project. The Froude-scale ATTILA testbed consists of a semi-span wing with powered tip-mounted proprotor reflecting the proprietary design of the Next Generation Civil TiltRotor (NGCTR). An overview of the ATTILA testbed, wind tunnel test procedures, team organisation and preliminary flutter results are presented. In line with pre-entry dynamic characterization tests, the wind-on test activities in the DNW Large Low-speed Facility (LLF) revealed notable force-dependent nonlinearity in the modal characteristics of, particularly, the wing torsion mode. Further dimensionality was added by early observations that damping in the rotor gimbal degree of freedom, attributed to stiction in the blade pitch mechanism, had the potential to substantially contribute to the damping of the fundamental wing-pylon modes. Nevertheless, the parallel exploitation of multiple monitoring and online modal estimation methodologies enabled a robust identification and safe test progression. The critical flutter mode was found to be configuration dependent, with the wing chord bending mode generally being marginally stable throughout most of the wind speed range, and the wing torsion mode displaying a sharp trend towards negative damping at higher speeds. Despite technical challenges, valuable test data was gathered to advance the experimental methods and support validation of the numerical tools used to obtained clearance for high-speed flight testing of the full-scale NGCTR Technology Demonstrator.
Helicopter aircrew are exposed to high levels of whole-body vibration (WBV) in fight operations, which may degrade their ride comfort and performance in the short-term, and contribute to some health issues in the long-term. This paper presents the latest development and flight test demonstration results of an active seat mount system that is designed to reduce helicopter aircrew WBV levels through active cancellation of the N/rev vibration peaks related to the helicopter main rotor speed. A prototype airworthy hardware of the active seat mount system has been developed based on previous bench-top-test designs to meet airframe integrity requirements for installation and flight testing on the Bell-412 helicopter. Extensive experimental results on human occupants using a shaker table facility and flight demonstrations on the NRC Bell-412 helicopter in representative flight conditions are presented and discussed. The active seat mount system has achieved significant reduction to the occupant WBV levels at the bottom seat cushion interface per ISO2631/MIL-STD-1472G metrics, and also showed effective mitigation to the occupant head vibrations. These investigations demonstrate that the active seat mount technology is a feasible solution for helicopter aircrew WBV mitigation.
Aerodynamic interactions impact multirotor vehicle performance throughout its entire flight envelope and change with vehicle orientation, attitude, and forward flight speed. This paper presents efforts in incorporating these interaction effects into a reduced-order numerical quadrotor model informed by experimental flight test data. The interaction model employed system identification tools to compensate for discrepancies between actual rotor performance data and a Blade Element Theory (BET) based baseline model. Incorporation of the interaction model derived from system identification techniques improved the accuracy of model predicted rotor performance. The interaction model also provided insight into interaction effects predominantly influencing rotor performance for multiple flight conditions. The results demonstrate the utility of system identification techniques for accurate multirotor modeling capabilities.
This paper presents a new approach, variant of the Direct Load Recognition (DLR) methodology, to estimate the main rotor (MR) pitch-link load on customer flights. The original DLR methodology is based on the combination of a harmonic decomposition and the use of Machine Learning algorithms. The DLR variant replaces the harmonic decomposition by a wavelet decomposition. The application of this paper consists in two parts. First, the comparison between the original DLR and DLR variant on prototype flight test data. Two results are highlighted in this part. The capacity of representation of the pitch-link load is better for the wavelet decomposition. The modelling of its coefficients enables to slightly improve the pitch-link load estimation, especially on the high load values having more impact on the fatigue computation. This first part allows to study the feasibility of the DLR variant to estimate the pitch-link load. The second part of this paper focuses on the application of the pitch-link load estimator built with DLR variant on the H175 fleet. From the estimated MR pitch-link load, the MR pitch horn damage is derived and compared to the Design Usage Spectrum (DUS), used today for the certification. The damage of all the studied customer aircraft is well below the DUS, showing a potential gain in component life time. The results of this paper manifest the advantage of the DLR methodology, and more precisely DLR variant methodology, for predictive maintenance on the MR pitch horn, that is to adapt the maintenance to the aircraft usage.
Previous work documented the use of IVHMS data on the U.S. Army's fleet of UH-60 Black Hawk helicopters to update the fatigue lives of six specific components on the A/L and M models. This paper documents a significant expansion of the level of data applied to the usage spectrum, as well as applying it to all components on the aircraft. As a design spectrum for the yet to be fielded Improved Turbine Engine (ITE) equipped UH-60M, changes due to new engine capability needed to be addressed. The new spectrum has been developed and is being used for planning of flight testing. The spectrum along with flight test loads will be used to generate fatigue lives for the new aircraft. Once deployed for several years the spectrum will be reviewed to determine if any changes are needed. This work highlights what the Army considers to be the most significant issues when applying monitored usage to critical fatigue components, and rationale for dealing with issues such as insufficient data for various purposes.
ABSTRACT The ability to model and evaluate aircraft performance prior to flight has generated a significant increase in safety margin in the flight testing of experimental aircraft. Prior to the artificial icing campaign for the AW609 aircraft, a flight model of predicted aerodynamic behavior was used to rapidly generate a control margin monitoring and warning system, which was implemented on-board the aircraft during testing to provide awareness of predicted aircraft behavior under icing conditions.
ABSTRACT Shipboard operations present a unique set of challenges to the pilot-vehicle system. This work addresses problems specific to piloted rotorcraft in the simulated shipboard environment, namely cueing and ship motion, and represents the completion of a three-year effort focused on fixed-base, pilot-in-the-loop rotorcraft flight simulations. Instructors from the United States Naval Test Pilot School, with extensive operational and test experience, participated in the study. Two cueing sets, one for the approach task and another for the hover task, were developed in order to provide intuitive guidance of cyclic and collective inputs. Data were gathered for each task with the cueing system both on and off. The evaluation criteria used to determine the usefulness of the provided cueing were based on pilot workload assessment, profile performance and inceptor activity. The approach task cueing provides the pilot with a preset approach profile defined by altitude and airspeed cueing, while the hover task cueing provides the pilot with a top-down view of helicopter position over the landing spot and a representation of the vehicle’s acceleration vector. Different control response types were assessed, as well as different ship motion intensities. Both tasks show that use of the developed cues allows pilots to achieve greater precision with less overall workload when compared to task performance without cueing available.
ABSTRACT Updates to the military rotorcraft handling qualities specification are currently being considered that address the high-speed flight regime envisioned for the Future Vertical Lift (FVL) platform of the US Army. The US Army's National Rotorcraft Technology Center (NRTC) project "Rotorcraft Handling Qualities Requirements for Future Configurations and Missions" was a U.S. Government and Industry co-funded three-year research project. A project team that features industry and academia have developed and evaluated a set of Mission Task Elements (MTEs) that are defined to address rotorcraft high-speed handling qualities. The High Speed Acceleration/Deceleration MTE was designed to provide suitable coverage in ADS-33 for handling qualities in Low/High Speed Transitional flight regimes (e.g. rotor-borne to wing-borne flight). The MTE objectives, descriptions, and performance criteria were developed via a series of piloted simulation sessions at each of the four teams' simulation facility. Formal evaluations were then conducted by US Army and contractor test pilots at the four simulator facilities, each featuring a unique high-speed platform, including two tiltrotor configurations, an X2 Technology compound helicopter, and a generic winged compound helicopter. To enhance the MTE evaluation process, baseline control law (CLAW) configurations were varied to achieve different handling qualities levels. Quantitative measures based on task performance and qualitative measures based on pilot ratings, comments and debrief questionnaires were used to assess MTE effectiveness. The piloted simulation results demonstrated that the High Speed Acceleration/ Deceleration MTE provided a suitable and effective means to evaluate Transitional handling qualities between low and high speed flight, although some refinements may still be warranted.
Items per page:
50
1 – 50 of 477