Detailed Emissions Characterization for Off-Road Applications: A DPF and non-DPF Engine Comparison
2022-01-0704
03/29/2022
- Event
- Content
- As agencies continue to focus on emissions compliance, low NOX discussions have started to propagate beyond the on-highway market. Off-road applications, which contribute to 29% of the PM emissions and 11% of the NOX emissions in California, are being reviewed to understand the technological challenges and requirements for improved emissions performance. To help facilitate an off-road low NOX technology demonstration, information from current engine and aftertreatment technologies required a detailed assessment. The following work will discuss the emissions characterization results from two non-road engine platforms. The intention of this study is to compare the emissions species from different approaches designed to meet Tier 4 Final emissions regulations. The platforms reflect available technology for DPF and non-DPF aftertreatment architectures. A detailed emissions characterization included gaseous emissions, particulate matter, particulate number, and an extensive list of non-regulated emission measurements (e.g. volatile organic compounds, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, and water soluble organic carbon). The engines were evaluated utilizing certification cycles, as well as, a low load application cycle developed from field applications. Results from this study indicate that while both applications meet Tier 4 final regulations, each engine platform has associated challenges. For example, the non-DPF engine reduces PM by 40% to 50%, while the DPF engine can reduce PM by 95% or more. The non-DPF engine, however, had better low load NOX reduction performance at 82% compared to the DPF engine at 67%. The tradeoff, though, was higher brake specific fuel consumption for the non-DPF engine. This work will provide valuable inputs to engine and aftertreatment simulation models, which will be utilized to evaluate candidate low NOX aftertreatment architectures.
- Citation
- Zavala, B., Premnath, V., and Sharp, C., "Detailed Emissions Characterization for Off-Road Applications: A DPF and non-DPF Engine Comparison," SAE Technical Paper 2022-01-0704, 2022, .